Showing posts with label john p. stevens high school. Show all posts
Showing posts with label john p. stevens high school. Show all posts

Saturday, October 31, 2026

October 31, 1986: The East Brunswick-Stevens Halloween Bowl

Flynn's game-ending sack

October 31, 1986, 40 years ago: For the 5th time in 3 seasons, East Brunswick High School and John P. Stevens High School play each other in football, at John E. McGowan Memorial Stadium, on Stevens' campus on the north side of Edison, Middlesex County, New Jersey.

J.P. Stevens (or just "Stevens" for shorter) opened in 1964, and first played EB in 1969, and had usually beaten them. The Hawks' wins over the Bears in 1977 and 1978 were not only key to them winning the Middlesex County Athletic Conference and Central Jersey Group IV Championships, but also made the difference in keeping E.B. out of the Central Jersey Group IV Playoffs. Another loss to Stevens kept EB out in 1981. EB were only 3-6 in 1982, but Stevens' team that year won it all, going 11-0, and is regarded as one of the best teams in Middlesex County football history.

In 1983, Stevens beat EB and made the Playoffs. In 1984, EB went to Stevens and beat them in the regular season, going on to win the MCAC title, finish the regular season undefeated, and reach and host the Central Jersey Group IV Final. But running back George Boothe, a key player, injured for the regular-season game, was healthy again, and he scored 3 touchdowns as Stevens beat EB, 27-26. A failed 2-point conversion became a "cursed team" moment for EB. It was our "Black Saturday."

In 1985, Stevens again went undefeated, beating EB by 1 point, 18-17, and then beating us again in the Central Jersey title game, 19-7. That game was moved to Stevens' crosstown rivals, Edison High, due to snow rendering their field unplayable, but Edison's was okay -- not that we could run or pass on it.

So going into the 1986 season, both teams had heavy losses due to graduation, but had enough talent to go for Conference and Sectional honors again. The regular-season matchup was set for Stevens, on October 31, Halloween Night. Stevens came in with a 22-game winning streak, not having lost since the '84 defeat by EB, and not just the Number 1 ranking in the County according to The Home News, but the Number 4 ranking in the State according to The Star-Ledger, the Newark-based Statewide newspaper. It was also their Homecoming, a crowd of over 5,000 came in.

EB were 3-2-1, having had both our Playoff chances and our GMC Red Division chances taken away the previous Saturday, in a 20-17 loss at Perth Amboy, where the officiating was, to put it politely, highly questionable. I was there, and I'm still questioning it, 40 years later. So we had a lot of frustrations and who better to take them out on than the team that had ruined our State Championship hopes 2 years in a row.

Both The Home News and radio station WCTC named it their Game of the Week. Bruce Johnson broadcast the game for WCTC; John Meggiolaro, Jimmy Allinder and Phil Hill did so for local cable station EBTV. But because of CTC's setup and Edison Township's own cable coverage, EBTV couldn't get space in the press box above the home stands. They had to set up over the visitor's side, at the south end's 30-yard-line, making for an awkward angle. It also exposed them to the weather, and it was unusually cold for Halloween. Then again, that made them feel like regular fans.

Stevens, coached by Tony Simonelli, wore their plain white helmets, with their home dark green jerseys and gold pants; while EB, coached by Marcus Borden, and like Simonelli he had taken his job for the 1983 season, wore their white helmets with a green center stripe, a script "Bears" on each side, and paw-print stickers for big plays, to go with all-white uniforms with green trim. Stevens kicked off at 7:00 PM sharp.

Neither team could score on its opening possession. On their 2nd, EB got a 34-yard field goal from left-footed kicker Josh Miller, who went on to become an NFL punter. On the Hawks' next possession, the Bears forced a fumble and recovered it in Stevens' territory, but could not capitalize, and I thought we would end up paying for that. Sure enough, Ray Patricco threw a 63-yard touchdown pass to Curtis Sharp. But the extra point by Leon Theodorou, whose field goal won the regular-season game the season before, was wide right, and the 1st quarter ended 6-3 to Stevens.

Early in the 2nd quarter, Bryan Fortay, a sophomore but already one of the most heralded quarterbacks in the State, found a wide-open Bill Breunig in the west corner of the south end zone, capping a long drive with an 8-yard touchdown pass. Miller's extra point put EB up, 10-6. Stevens were driving as the clock ran out in the 1st half, but Ken Prus intercepted Patricco to end the threat and the half, with the score still 10-6.

In the middle of the 3rd quarter, Stevens had a 4th & 4 on EB's 33, and Patricco found Tony Mayers wide open. Had he caught the ball, he would have been unopposed for a touchdown, but he dropped the pass. But on their next possession, he didn't drop a pass, and took it 28 yards for a go-ahead touchdown. But when Stevens went for the two-point conversion, Mayers tripped in the end zone, leaving the score at Hawks 12, Bears 10.

Miller missed a 43-yard field goal attempt. A pass interference call wiped out an interception by Prus and gave Stevens a 1st down. But a strong defensive stand, led by linebacker Robb Schaffer, forced Stevens to punt. Breunig took Mayers' punt on his own 40, then handed it to Prus, who headed for the east sideline, and took off, untouched, and took it to the house. It was the kind of end-around play that Stevens, with the now-graduated George Boothe, had used so effectively against EB the preceding 2 years. Miller added the extra point, and the 3rd quarter ended Bears 17, Hawks 12.

In the 4th quarter, the Bears held the Hawks on one series, then another, holding them on 4th down by maybe 8 inches according to the officials' measurement, with 4:09 to go. A Fortay-to-Prus pass on 3rd & 10 gained a 1st down with 3:06 to go.

Stevens' defense held, but on Fortay's punt, Stevens went for the block, but, instead, were called for roughing the kicker, giving the Bears a new 1st down with 2:14 to go. It was the kind of penalty that usually happened against East Brunswick -- called correctly, or otherwise -- rather than in their favor.

With 1:03 to go, Fortay threw 31 yards to Prus for what could have been a touchdown, but the Bears were flagged for holding. Stevens got the ball back on their own 27 with 55 seconds to go, but a dropped pass, a completed pass for a 1st down, an incomplete pass to stop the clock, and a sack of Patricco by John Flynn, and the clock ran out: East Brunswick had won, 17-12, ending J.P. Stevens' winning streak; throwing E.B.'s fans, myself included, into ecstasy; and throwing both the Greater Middlesex Conference Red Division and the Central Jersey Group IV power point totals into chaos.

On EBTV, Phil Hill said, "J.P. Stevens has been tricked, and East Brunswick has been treated." And so it was true. That was a great night. Along with winning the Middlesex County baseball title the preceding June, and the County basketball title (also beating Stevens) the following February, one of the greatest nights I had as an EBHS student. We knew our chances of making the Playoffs or getting even a share of the Division title were slim, so this win made our season.

The game is on YouTube. I recently watched it for the first time since it happened. It felt great. Maybe not as great as it did that night, but still great after four decades.

The following Friday night, we beat Cedar Ridge of Old Bridge, 28-0. That was our 8th game, and thus the last one for which any "power points" we gained would count. (It's complicated, and I won't explain it here.) The Friday night after that, we beat Sayreville, 33-14, to finish with a record of 6-2-1.

A weird thing: In my father's senior year at Barringer High School in Newark, in my mother's senior year at Belleville High School, and in my senior year at East Brunswick High School, the football teams at each school ended up winning 6, losing 2, and tying 1. And none made the State Playoffs. Of course, Dad and Mom didn't have the State Playoffs to make, as the NJSIAA didn't start them until 1974. Even more unfortunately, when my sister was a senior at EBHS, the team didn't do nearly as well, breaking the pattern.

Under most circumstances, 6-2-1 would have been considered a really good season. But losing our 1st-ever home night game, 22-0 to Madison Central, and then getting hosed by the officials away to Perth Amboy left us feeling a bit under-satisfied.

Then came Thanksgiving Day, where, without our even playing, a combination of results left us with a share of the Division title. It was a weird occurrence in a season of weird occurrences, but it gave us a championship.

Another oddity: It was Josh Miller, our kicker, who became the only player in the 1st 60 years of EBHS football to play in the NFL -- and as a punter. He was an All-Pro with the Pittsburgh Steelers, and won a Super Bowl XXXIX ring with the New England Patriots. He is now a successful radio show host.
Fortay wasn't so lucky. Although he led us to another Conference Championship in 1987, we got wrecked by Madison Central in the Playoffs, and they did it to us again the next year, both in the regular season and in the Playoffs. He did, however, also help our basketball team win the Middlesex County Championship in 1987, and reach the Tournament Final again in 1989.

He was still recruited to play at the University of Miami, already a program producing a string of good quarterbacks (and receivers, and linebackers, and defensive backs), by head coach Jimmy Johnson. But Johnson got an offer he couldn't refuse: The head coaching job of the Dallas Cowboys.

Miami brought in Dennis Erickson, who had coached Timm Rosenbach at Washington State. But he was committed to other quarterbacks Miami already had: First, the unrelated Dennis Erickson, who led them to the National Championship in 1989; then, Gino Torretta. who led them to the National Championship in 1991, and nearly another in 1992, when he won the Heisman Trophy. Based on those results, it can hardly be said that he made the wrong decision.

Fortay transferred to Rutgers, leading them to a 6-5 season in 1991 and 7-4 in 1992, including another Halloween thriller, tossing a touchdown pass on the last play of the game to give RU a 50-49 Homecoming win over Virginia Tech. But a 26-24 loss to the University of Cincinnati the next week ended RU's bowl hopes.
Fortay went undrafted. His only pro football experience would be in 1995: First, in the World League of American Football, an NFL-sponsored league that played in the Spring, with the Frankfurt Galaxy in Germany; then, in the Fall, with the Miami Hooters of the Arena Football League. He had just turned 24, but his football career was over. He joined his father's business, training racehorses; and then went to law school, and has practiced law for insurance companies. He turns 55 in 2 days, and appears to have done well for himself.

I'm reminded of something the late British TV show host Clive James once said: "Achievement without fame can be a very rewarding life, while fame without achievement is no life at all."

As it turned out, though, the most famous member of the EBHS football teams of 1985, '86 and '87 was a linebacker, who had come to America from Türkiye with his family. He was a good player by high school standards. He went to the University of Pennsylvania, and Columbia University School of Law, became a radio talk show host, and created politically-themed program The Young Turks. His name is Cenk Uygur.
I knew Miller and Fortay, and spoke with them many times. I did not know Uygur well, and the only times we did talk, it was about the team, never about politics.

Sunday, December 1, 2024

December 1, 1984: East Brunswick's Black Saturday

The main entrance to East Brunswick High School
-- after renovations made in 2000.
It would have appeared differently in 1984.

December 1, 1984: New Jersey completes its high school football State Playoffs. Among the games played is the Central Jersey Group IV Final, at Jay Doyle Field in East Brunswick, New Jersey.

I was there. I saw this game. I have been trying to forget it ever since.

East Brunswick High School, in Middlesex County, opened in 1958, and had been playing football since 1961. In 1966 and 1972, it won the Central Jersey Group IV Championship. But that was under the old system, based on total wins. In 1974, the New Jersey State Interscholastic Athletic Association (NJSIAA) instituted a Playoff system, based on "power points": A team got 2 points for every win, and 1 point for every game won by a team it beat.

Under this system, John P. Stevens High School of Edison, also in Middlesex County and a Middlesex County Athletic Conference (MCAC) opponent of E.B., won the Central Jersey Group IV Championship in 1977, 1978 and 1982, also making the Playoffs in 1983. East Brunswick had made it only once, in 1980, losing in the Semifinal.

John P. Stevens was the President of the Board of Education in Edison. He oversaw the building of Edison High School in 1955, but died soon thereafter. When a 2nd high school opened, on the north side of town, it was named for him. As a result, his name is on the dedication plaques of both schools.

But in 1984, the year I entered EBHS as a sophomore, E.B. won its 1st 6 games. In just his 2nd season as head coach, Marcus Borden had built a team based on strong line play and quick-strike capability. The 7th game was at Stevens' John E. McGowan Stadium, on October 27. E.B. beat J.P., 26-6. It was a dominating performance, and it went a long way toward the Bears earning the MCAC Championship. I was there: It was Stevens' Homecoming, and 5,000 of their fans went home angry.

They would get their revenge. Their big running back, George Boothe, was unavailable for this game due to injury. He returned, and helped them make the Playoffs. E.B. won their Semifinal over Hunterdon Central of Flemington, and then beat Colonia of Woodbridge on Thanksgiving Day to clinch the MCAC title and our 1st undefeated regular season. Stevens won their Semifinal, over Middletown North of Monmouth County, but lost their Thanksgiving game against crosstown Edison.

The local newspaper, then named The Central New Jersey Home News, ranked E.B. Number 1 in Middlesex County. So did another nearby paper, The News Tribune. These 2 papers would merge in 1995, forming The Home News Tribune. The Statewide newspaper, the Newark-based The Star-Ledger, ranked E.B. Number 2 in the entire State, behind Union of Union County. We were 10-0, and Stevens as 7-3. And we had the home-field advantage for the Final. We were heavily favored to win our 1st real "State Championship" in the sport.
Jay Doyle Field -- also noticeably altered,
well after 1984

But we couldn't stop Boothe. He scored 3 of their 4 touchdowns, the 1st on an end-around on which he wasn't even touched, putting the Hawks up, 27-20 in the 4th quarter. But the Bears had come from 27-13 down to beat Colonia, 33-27, just 9 days earlier, so the thought was there that we could do it again.

The Bears did come back, and scored a touchdown to make it 27-26 with a minute and a half to go. Remembering the Orange Bowl at the beginning of the year, when Nebraska's Tom Osborne went for the 2-point conversion and the National Championship against the University of Miami, and not getting it, and losing 31-30 -- but forgetting that, unlike college football at the time, New Jersey's State Playoffs did have a provision for overtime -- Borden went for the 2-point conversion.

Steve Hughes, who would be named Middlesex County Offensive Player of the Year by The Home News, found running back Deric Rowe wide open in the end zone. It was 3:37 PM. Don't bet me on the time. Rowe later said he lost the ball in the Sun. It hit him in the chest, slipped through his fingers, and fell to the grass. It was still 27-26.

We got the ball back one last time, but it was no use: Stevens 27, East Brunswick 26. Our undefeated State Championship season was gone. And, yes, 40 years later, it still hurts. Every time that score comes up, in any sport, I cringe.

Twice, I walked out of Jay Doyle Field in tears. The 2nd time was after graduation. The 1st time was this one, a game that became known as Black Saturday. I was spoiled over the 1st 10 games. I waited a long time for that 1 more win.

Deric played basketball for us, too, and we still cheered him every time he got the ball. But this was E.B.'s "Bill Buckner moment" -- 2 years before Buckner had his own. There would be other close calls, including another 1-point loss to Stevens in next year's regular season, costing us the Conference Championship; and another loss to them in the 1985 State Final. But E.B. football hadn't won a "State Championship" (officially, Central Jersey Group IV Championship) since 1972, and not at all under the current system.

Finally, we did it again on December 5, 2004, against Shore Conference power Jackson Memorial, at Rutgers Stadium in Piscataway. Borden was still the head coach. I was there. We did it again in 2009, beating Brick Memorial, another Shore Conference school, in a snowstorm at The College of New Jersey (formerly Trenton State College) in Ewing. I was at that one, too.

There is a tragic postscript to that 1984 Final: Both Deric Rowe and George Boothe ended up in legal trouble. Rowe played football at Kansas State University, but dropped out, and served time in prison for armed robbery, carjacking and kidnapping. Last I heard, he was free, and living in the San Diego suburbs.

Boothe played at the University of Connecticut, but fell into drug use there, and became Central Jersey's "O.J. Simpson" -- the difference being that he was convicted for killing his girlfriend, in Atlanta in 1994. He was eventually released, and, at last check, was living in Connecticut.