June 7, 1966, 60 years ago: Major League Baseball holds its 2nd annual Amateur Draft. The top pick goes to the team that had the worst record the season before: The New York Mets.
They chose Steve Chilcott, a 17-year-old catcher from Antelope Valley High School in the Los Angeles suburb of Lancaster, California.
What happened to Steve Chilcott? A baserunning blunder wrecked his throwing shoulder. He never reached the major leagues, and he played his last professional game in 1972, only 24 years old. He moved to Santa Barbara, and became a firefighter and a contractor. In a 2005 interview, he said, "I've had a good life, although, at first, it was hard for me to find things to do, because I had such a desire to be a professional athlete. I had to find my place in the world."
With the 2nd pick, the Kansas City Athletics chose Reggie Jackson, an outfielder from Arizona State University.
There were other good picks in that draft. The Houston Astros chose pitcher Wayne Twitchell. The Boston Red Sox chose pitcher Ken Brett. The Washington Senators chose outfielder Tom Grieve. The Cleveland Indians chose pitcher John Curtis. The Cincinnati Reds chose pitcher Gary Nolan. The Pittsburgh Pirates chose shortstop (later 3rd baseman) Richie Hebner. The Chicago White Sox chose outfielder Carlos May.
That was just in the 1st Round. In the 2nd Round, the White Sox chose catcher Johnny Oates. In the 3rd Round, the St. Louis Cardinals chose pitcher Clay Kirby, and the Minnesota Twins chose 3rd baseman Steve Garvey. (He didn't sign with them. Two years later, the Los Angeles Dodgers drafted him as a 1st baseman, and he signed with them.)
In the 5th Round, the Astros chose catcher Cliff Johnson, and the Pirates chose shortstop (later 2nd baseman) Dave Cash. In the 6th Round, the Pirates chose 2nd baseman Gene Clines. In the 8th Round, the Dodgers chose pitcher Charlie Hough. In the 9th Round, the California Angels chose pitcher Ken Forsch, and the Dodgers chose outfielder (later shortstop) Bill Russell.
With perhaps the most interesting pick in the draft, in the 10th Round, the New York Yankees chose a lefthanded pitcher from the University of Alabama: Ken Stabler. Instead of baseball, he chose football, and became a Hall of Fame quarterback with the Oakland Raiders. (John Elway, who later actually did play one season in the Yankee system, followed the same path.)
In the 15th Round, the Dodgers chose catcher (later 2nd baseman) Ted Sizemore. In the 19th Round, the Dodgers chose 3rd baseman Ron Cey. In the 20th Round, the Angels chose pitcher Dave LaRoche. In the 31st Round, the Chicago Cubs chose pitcher Bill Stoneman, and the Angels chose pitcher Bill Bonham. And in the 32nd Round, the Mets chose 2nd baseman Kurt Bevacqua.
So while Reggie turned out to be the best player in that Draft, he was far from the only good player who the Mets overlooked. But why did they overlook him? Arizona State head coach Bobby Winkles, who later managed the A's after Reggie left them, told him that the Mets were concerned that he was a black man with a white girlfriend. This was in 1966, a year before the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that all laws against interracial marriage were unconstitutional.
In fact, Reggie's girlfriend, Jennie Campos, was a Mexican-American, who faced prejudice as well. Reggie and Jennie married, but it didn't last, as Reggie's wandering eye was as active as his batting eye. But he has managed to keep his private life mostly private. There have been no public stories about him mistreating women.
With Reggie, the A's moved to Oakland in 1968, won 5 straight American League Western Division titles from 1971 to 1975, and won 3 straight World Series from 1972 to 1974. He signed with the Yankees for the 1977 season, and led them to back-to-back World Series wins, also winning an AL Eastern Division title in 1980 and an AL Pennant in 1981. After his relationship with team owner George Steinbrenner went from great to terrible, he signed with the Angels, and helped them to AL West titles in 1982 and 1986.
He retired with 563 career home runs, reached the postseason 11 times in 21 seasons, won 6 Pennants and 5 World Series, including the Series Most Valuable Player award twice, and was a 1st-year-of-eligibility electee to the Baseball Hall of Fame.
Having Reggie wouldn't have helped the Mets much. Maybe it would have been better for Cub fans in 1969, since they probably wouldn't have had a big lead to blow, so it's less painful for them. And it would have reversed the result of the 1973 World Series, when Reggie homered in Game 7, and the A's beat the Mets.
But just as the A's players took their earliest possible chances to bolt from team owner Charlie Finley, his cheapness, and his micromanaging, the opposite happened with the similarly cheap president of the Mets, M. Donald Grant: He got rid of his good players before they demanded "too much." Can you imagine George Steinbrenner seeing Reggie Jackson playing the 1976 season for a National League team, and then going after a Mets legend, and making him a bigger star with the Yankees? So, having Reggie on their team might have ended up actually being more painful for Met fans.












