Hard to believe, but the 2018 Major League Baseball season is upon us. Opening Day for the Yankees is Thursday, March 29. First pitch, away to the Toronto Blue Jays, is scheduled for 7:07 PM. The home opener is on Monday, April 2, against the Tampa Bay Rays, at 1:05 PM.
This guide is for all visiting fans, designed to make the trip to Yankee Stadium as enjoyable as possible, and to keep you from getting hurt.
I will put aside my usual insults for various opposing teams, and I will watch my language as well. This post will be rated PG. For those of you who watch ESPN, no, that doesn't stand for Peter Gammons.
Before You Go. This is the time to buy your tickets, before the season starts, and do it online. If you don't have tickets already, you're may be out of luck. But try StubHub or a similar site anyway. You'll have better luck, price-wise, with them than with the scalpers.
The weather is, of course, a factor. It can be chilly in New York in April, and starting in May and running through the rest of the regular season, it can be hot. The stands are not covered, so you'll have to go under the stands to avoid rain if it comes. Once you know when you're going, wait until the day before you leave, and check the online weather reports.
Tickets. More than any other team, the Yankees are hard to get tickets for -- because most of the seats that go unsold are insanely expensive. The Yankees averaged 39,835 fans per game last season, 1st in the American League, and more than any in Major League Baseball except the Los Angeles Dodgers, St. Louis Cardinals and San Francisco Giants. So right after you next get paid, order 'em.
The only seats that tend to stay empty are the Field MVP seats, which only get filled for Red Sox, Mets and postseason games, and those are basically celebrities who could afford them – some thanks to the Fox Network.
Do not trust the scalpers, and there will be loads of them. Back in the 1980s, I bought a ticket "right over the dugout." Yeah, way over the dugout in the upper deck. The next night, I bought one "right on the left-field foul line." Yeah, right behind the left-field foul pole. To make matters worse, the Yanks lost both games!
If you order from the club through Ticketmaster, you may be able to snag tickets in the Field Level (behind the big walkway, a.k.a. The Moat, that separates the expensive sections from the insanely expensive ones), for $125. In the Main Level, the back of the lower deck, they could be had for $90. In the Terrace Level, the 2nd deck, they could be had for $60. In the Grandstand Level, the upper deck, you could get them for $30.
Of course, Ticketmaster adds a surcharge. But then, if you root for the Red Sox, Giants, Philadelphia Phillies or Chicago Cubs, being used to high prices, you're probably not surprised at any of the inconveniences, from the prices to the surcharges to the jumping-through-hoops to get them.
Do not buy a ticket for the Bleachers. If someone offers you a free ticket in the Bleachers, do not take it. Face value is $15, but even free, it will not be worth it. Ignoring this warning may be the biggest mistake of your life, especially if you are a Red Sox fan. The "Bleacher Creatures," those are hard-core people out there. If you are familiar with what happens at European soccer games, note that this is one of the few places in North American sports that can get like that. Of course, as I well know, Fenway, particularly its bleachers, is another.
And remember, those of you who are Red Sox fans: After the rise of your team during the Nomar-Pedro era, into the Papi-Schilling-Youkilis-Papelbon years, and now into the Pedroia years, these people now hate you almost as much as you hate them. And, like Sox fans, they like to drink. They really, really like to drink. Do not say I did not warn you.
If you root for the Mets and you want to see an interleague game at Yankee Stadium, the same thing applies. If you root for another American League Eastern Division team -- the Baltimore Orioles, the Tampa Bay Rays or the Toronto Blue Jays -- you'll be better off, but still don't go for the Bleachers. And if you root for anyone else, still: Think of the Bleachers as the barn, or the basement, in a horror movie: Don't go in.
If you want to attend a promotion, here are some of the better-known ones for which to order tickets: Calendar Day, April 8 vs. Baltimore; Didi Gregorious Bat Day, May 12 vs. Oakland; Old-Timers' Day, June 17 vs. Tampa Bay (likely to honor the 40th Anniversary of the 1978 World Series win, as that's the anniversary of Ron Guidry's 18-strikeout game against the California Angels); Collectible Truck Day (toy truck), July 29 vs. Kansas City; Collectible Cup Day, August 10 vs. Texas; Cap Day, August 15 vs. Tampa Bay; and August 18 vs. Toronto, celebrating the 20th Anniversary of the 1998 World Series win.
Either Old-Timers' Day or the 1998 celebration could also feature an as-yet-unannounced addition to Monument Park -- although I don't know who that would be for in either case. Who's left that deserves it? From 1978, Lou Piniella? Sparky Lyle? They're the only guys from that team who had YES Network Yankeeography episodes but not yet a Plaque. 1998... Joe Girardi? They could now put his final managerial stats on the Plaque. (It's not like the Steinbrenner Brothers are going to bring back a former manager, like their father George frequently did.)
Bobblehead Days will be for David Wells on April 23 vs. Minnesota, in honor of the 20th Anniversary of his perfect game against them (May 17, 1998); Aaron Judge in Jedi robe for Star Wars Night on May 4 vs. Cleveland ("May the 4th be with you" is one of the lamest jokes in pop culture history); Ron Guidry on June 14 vs. Tampa Bay, in honor of the Anniversary of his 18-strikeout game; CC Sabathia on July 27 vs. Kansas City; and Brett Gardner on August 31 vs. Detroit, although it wouldn't surprise me to see general manager Brian Cashman trade him for several "prospects" a month before that (the trading deadline being July 31).
Getting There. Getting to New York is fairly easy. However, I do not recommend driving, especially if you are a Red Sox fan and have Sox or other New England sports paraphernalia on it (bumper sticker, license-plate holder, decals, etc.). Chances are, it won't get vandalized, but you never know.
For those of you who are not Red Sox fans: If you are coming from Baltimore or other points south, take Interstate 95 North up through New Jersey (this includes the New Jersey Turnpike), over the George Washington Bridge, and then Interstate 87, the Major Deegan Expressway, south to Exit 5 for The Stadium. (William F. Deegan was one of the founders of the American Legion, and a Democratic politician in New York.)
If you are coming from Cleveland, Toronto, or other points west, find your way to Interstate 80, which will also flow into the GW Bridge. Be warned, though: That bridge is notorious for traffic delays.
In fact, it would be a shame if you came to New York only for one baseball game -- especially if it is your first visit. My recommendation, then, is to make it a weekend visit, and get a hotel outside New York City, preferably in New Jersey, where it will be a lot cheaper, and you can leave your car in a safe parking lot. Most cities and towns in New Jersey have bus or train service, with New Jersey Transit as the main (but not only) carrier, into Manhattan, and from there, you can take the Subway up to The Stadium. Yes, the bus and the train will cost a bit, but the money you'll save with an outside-the-City hotel will more than make up for it. Look up njtransit.com for details.
And you really shouldn't drive in The City. I've heard it said that Boston drivers come in 2 classes, depending on how big their car is: Homicidal and suicidal. New York drivers are the same way, and traffic is every bit as bad as what you're used to. If you're coming from New England, approaching New York from the north, you can probably find something affordable in Westchester County or Connecticut, and then take the Metro-North Commuter Railroad in.
If you are coming from New England, and you feel that you must drive, it's 208 miles by road from Downtown Crossing in Boston to Yankee Stadium II, 206 miles from Fenway to the House That Steinbrenner Built.
If you're going from Boston, or anywhere else in Massachusetts, take the Massachusetts Turnpike, Interstate 90, to Exit 9 for Interstate 84 South, into Connecticut. At Hartford, take Exit 86 to Interstate 91 South, taking it all the way to the end, switching to I-95 South at New Haven.
If you're starting out in Rhode Island, simply get on I-95. If you're starting out anywhere in Connecticut, take any highway that leads to I-95, whether it's I-91, I-395, U.S. Route 7 or Connecticut State Route 8.
If you're starting out in New Hampshire, take I-93 to I-495 to the Mass Pike (so you don't have to go through Boston itself) and then follow the directions for starting from Massachusetts as listed above. If you're starting out in Maine, take I-95 across New Hampshire and into Massachusetts, then take I-495 and follow the directions from New Hampshire. If you're starting out in Vermont, I'll get to that in a moment, because the directions are a bit different.
If you're only going to one game, and not "doing the city," then, once you're in New York, follow signs for Interstate 278, the Bruckner Expressway. (Henry Bruckner was a Bronx Borough President.) Take that to Interstate 87 North, the Deegan. Do not be confused by signs for the Robert F. Kennedy Bridge: It's the new name for the Triboro Bridge, and we know Bobby Kennedy was connected more to Massachusetts, even though he represented New York State in the U.S. Senate from January 4, 1965 to June 6, 1968.
Anyway, you don't want the RFK Bridge, you want the Deegan, taking Exit 5 for Yankee Stadium. The "classic address" is 161st Street & River Avenue, and that hasn't changed with the new Stadium, it's just on the other side of 161st. The official mailing address is 1 East 161st Street, Bronx, NY 10451, so you can use that for your GPS. It's 6 miles uptown from Midtown Manhattan.
The one New England State that's an exception to the above sets of directions is Vermont. If you're starting out there, take US-4 into New York State, across the Hudson River, and take I-87 South, known first as the Northway and then, once you get through Albany, as the New York State Thruway, on down, until you cross the City Line into The Bronx and it becomes the Deegan. You'll still take Exit 5 to get to the Stadium, unless you get a hotel and head there first.
Boston, Philadelphia, Baltimore and Washington are too close to fly to New York, and once you factor in fooling around with everything you gotta do at each airport, it doesn't really save you much time compared to driving, the bus or the train.
Anyone coming in from outside the Northeast Corridor, if you can afford to fly, that is probably your best option. Even though Newark Liberty International Airport in New Jersey isn't very good. John F. Kennedy International Airport in southern Queens is good only for international travel, if that. And LaGuardia International Airport (named for the 1934-45 Mayor) in northern Queens is a joke – and not just because it's close to Rikers Island (site of the City's prison) and the Mets' ballpark. (I know, I know: "What's the difference?" When you're a Met fan, the sentence never ends, and nobody tries to escape to Yankeedom.)
If you can afford Amtrak, the train is a good option if you're coming from the Northeast Corridor or Chicago. If it's the Corridor, you can come to New York and it will take less than 5 hours. If it's Chicago or the South, the ride will be overnight, and you can get a decent night's sleep.
But anything farther than that, and it will require more than one night. If you're coming from Cleveland or Detroit, you're talking about boarding a train in the middle of the night, which is no good. And if you're coming from Toronto, there's only one train per day in each direction: You'll be leaving in the morning and arriving too late to catch that night's game, and reversing the trip, too early to attend the next day's game.
Bus schedules are better, with far more runs to New York from most cities. But riding the bus is no picnic, especially from outside the Northeast Corridor. I've ridden buses from New York to Pittsburgh, Cleveland, Detroit and Chicago, and back. If you can't afford to fly and don't want to drive that far, the bus is better than the train. But if you can afford to fly, do it.
Once In the City. Pennsylvania Station, a.k.a. Penn Station, is between 31st and 33rd Streets, between 7th and 8th Avenues. Port Authority Bus Terminal is between 40th and 42nd Streets, between 8th and 9th Avenues. They are one stop apart on the Subway's A, C and E trains. Outside Port Authority, there is a statue of Jackie Gleason dressed as bus driver Ralph Kramden on The Honeymooners, one of a series of statues commissioned by cable network TV Land.
Ralphie Boy's statue, in front of the Port Authority entrance,
on 8th Avenue between 40th and 41st Streets
Don't read the New York Post. Like anything owned by Rupert Murdoch, it's a bunch of right-wing lies with an occasionally good sports section added. The Times and the Daily News, however, are not only manned by responsible journalists, but have great sports sections.
The Times is the face New York City likes to show the rest of the world. The Daily News is the face the City prefers to show itself. The Post is a face only a mother could love. Not my mother, though. Nor hers.
The front entrance to Penn Station and Madison Square Garden,
on 7th Avenue at 32nd Street
The city of New Amsterdam, and the colony of New Netherland, were founded by the Dutch in 1624. In 1664, the English took over, and named both the city and the colony New York, for the Duke of York, the brother of King Charles II. As none of Charles' many children were legitimate, when he died in 1685, that brother became King James II -- and his reign did not end well, and let's leave it at that.
New York County, a.k.a. the Borough of Manhattan, was also named for James. "Manahatta" was an Indian word meaning "island of many hills." Kings County was named for King Charles, but the Dutch name Breuckelen stuck, and it became the City, and after 1898 the Borough, of Brooklyn. Queens County, or the Borough of Queens, was named for King Charles' Portuguese wife, Catherine of Braganza. Richmond County was named for one of Charles' sons, Charles Lennox, Earl of Richmond, but the Dutch name Staaten Eylandt stuck, and it became the Borough of Staten Island.
And Jonas Bronck settled the land north of Manhattan, which became known as Bronck's Land, which somehow morphed into "The Bronx." Apparently, the "The" became attached because of the Bronx River that passes through it, as rivers are still frequently called that: The Hudson is, although never "The Harlem" or "The East." Anyway, it's the Borough of The Bronx and Bronx County.
New York has been the most populous city in America since surpassing Philadelphia in the post-Revolutionary period, and now has about 8.6 million people living in the Five Boroughs. About 23.8 million live in the New York Metropolitan Area, a.k.a. the New York Tri-State Area, which includes The City, Long Island, and the Lower Hudson Valley in the State of New York; Northern and Central New Jersey; and the Connecticut Counties of Fairfield, Litchfield and New Haven.
View from Rockefeller Center,
with the Empire State Building in the center,
the new World Trade Center in the background,
and the Jersey City Waterfront,
including the Goldman Sachs Tower, to the right.
On the East Side, the Avenues go 5th, Madison, Park (which takes the place of 4th Avenue above Union Square), Lexington, 3rd, 2nd, 1st, York, East End. Numbered Streets will reach an address of 1 at 5th, 100 at Park, 200 at 3rd, 300 at 2nd, 400 at 1st. On the Lower East Side, this extends to 500 at Avenue A, 600 at Avenue B, 700 at Avenue C and 800 at Avenue D. (A, B, C and D, hence the nickname for this neighborhood: "Alphabet City.") The Franklin D. Roosevelt Drive (FDR Drive), formerly the East River Drive and once so dangerous it was called the Falling Down Roadway, separates the island from the East River.
On the West Side, the Avenues go 6th, a.k.a. Avenue of the Americas, Lenox Avenue or Malcolm X Blvd. above Central Park; 7th, a.k.a. Fashion Avenue, or Adam Clayton Powell Jr. Blvd. above Central Park; 8th, Central Park West above 59th Street, or Frederick Douglass Blvd. above Central Park; 9th, Columbus Avenue above 59th, or Morningside Drive above 110th; 10th, Amsterdam Avenue above 59th; 11th, West End Avenue above 59th, merging with Broadway at 108th; and Riverside Drive. The West Side Highway, a.k.a. the Joe DiMaggio Highway, separates the island from the Hudson River.
The north-south numbered Avenues start with 1 at their southern ends, and the addresses go up going Uptown, but there's no set pattern (such as every X blocks = 100 house numbers), and they vary as to where they begin:
* Broadway, The Battery, at the island's southern tip.
* 1st and 2nd, Houston Street -- roughly, Zero Street. And that's pronounced HOW-stin, not HEW-stin like the Texas city.
* 3rd, 9th Street.
* Lexington, 21st Street.
* Park, 32nd Street. Park Avenue South extends to 17th Street.
* Madison, 23rd Street, at Madison Square.
* 5th, Washington Square North -- roughly, 6th Street.
* 6th, Franklin Street -- the only numbered Avenue below Houston, so think of it as about -12th Street.
* 7th, 11th Street. 7th Avenue South extends to Carmine Street, roughly at Houston.
* 8th, Bleecker Street -- roughly, 10th Street at that point, although the way it curves makes it end up as more like 2nd Street.
* 9th, Gansevoort Street -- roughly, 12th Street.
* 10th and 11th, 13th Street.
* 12th, 22nd Street.
And then there's the Squares, which usually aren't square. Most of these are intersections of Broadway with the Avenues, but not all. Washington Square is at 8th Street and 5th Avenue; Union Square at 14th Street and Park Avenue South; Madison Square at 23rd Street and 5th Avenue; Herald Square at 34th Street and 6th Avenue; Times Square at 42nd (actually 45th) Street and 7th Avenue; Columbus Circle at 59th Street and 8th Avenue; Lincoln Square at 66th Street and Columbus Avenue; and Verdi Square at 72nd Street and Amsterdam Avenue.
Times Square: 42nd Street, 5th Avenue and Broadway
Central Park runs from 59th to 110th Streets, from 5th to 8th Avenues. In addition to Columbus Circle, it is cornered by Grand Army Plaza at 59th & 5th, Frawley Circle at 110th & 8th, and Duke Ellington Circle at 110th & 5th.
Below 14th Street, the streets frequently don't follow the grid. The fact that the buildings there are, and look, older lends the area a "film noir" look. If you're a comic book fan, there's a running gag that Metropolis, hometown of the optimistic superhero Superman, is Manhattan north of 14th Street on a beautiful spring day; while Gotham City, hometown of the brooding crimefighter Batman, is Manhattan south of 14th Street, a few minutes after midnight, on a cold rainy day in November.
Despite horror stories from recent period-piece TV productions like Life On Mars and The Bronx Is Burning, the New York Subway system is not the scary place it was in the 1970s and '80s. If you can handle the Boston T's Green Line, or Chicago's El, you can handle the New York Subway.
ZIP Codes in The Bronx begin with the digits 104. (Manhattan, 100, 101 or 102; Staten Island, 103; the Lower Hudson Valley, 105 to 109; Queens, 110, 111, 113, 114 and 116; Brooklyn, 112; Long Island, 115, 117, 118 and 119.) The Area Code used to be 212 for the entire City, but in 1984, Area Code 718 was split off to serve Brooklyn, Queens and Staten Island. The Bronx joined it in 1992. 718 is now overlaid by 347, 917 and 929. The Consolidated Edison company, or "Con Edison" or "Con Ed," runs the City's electricity.
So where does the City's nickname, the Big Apple, come from? There are plenty of theories, including a debunked one about a brothel owner named Eve. In his 1909 book The Wayfarer in New York, Edward S. Martin wrote, "Kansas is apt to see in New York a greedy city... It inclines to think that the big apple gets a disproportionate share of the national sap."
But this earliest known usage didn't catch on. John J. Fitz Gerald, horse racing reporter for the New York Morning Telegraph, first used it on May 3, 1921: "J.P. Smith, with Tippity Witchel and others of the L.T. Bauer string, is scheduled to start for 'the big apple' to-morrow." He used it frequently thereafter. Supposedly, jazz musicians soon took it up, and spread the name across the country. Variations include Los Angeles as the Big Orange and Tampa as the Big Guava.
About 36 percent of the City's population is foreign-born. The racial breakdown is 33 percent non-Hispanic white, 29 percent Hispanic (white or black), 25 percent African-American, and 12 percent Asian.
Non-Hispanic whites have slightly less than a majority in Manhattan (48 percent), non-Hispanic whites still have a slight plurality over non-Hispanic blacks in Brooklyn (35 to 34 percent), The Bronx is majority Hispanic (53 percent), non-Hispanic whites have the slimmest of margins over Hispanics in Queens (both about 27 percent) with Asians close behind at 23 percent, with Staten Island being the whitest (64 percent), most conservative, most bigoted, and all-around nastiest Borough.
Among Hispanics, Puerto Ricans outnumber Dominicans 2 to 1 and Mexicans 4 to 1. Among blacks, there is roughly an even split between the descendants of Caribbeans (the Jamaica neighborhood of Queens does have a considerable number of Jamaicans) and those whose ancestors were taken directly from Africa to America. In each case, they are mostly the descendants of slaves, but that would not be true for the City's recent immigrants from Africa.
Breaking it down among Asians, about 5 percent of the City's population is Chinese, 3 percent Middle Eastern, 2.7 percent Indian, 1 percent Korean, and Filipinos, Japanese and Vietnamese, in that order, having less than 1 percent. Aside from Lower Manhattan's Chinatown, most of the City's Chinese live in Queens, particularly in or around Flushing. Queens and Brooklyn have most of the City's Middle Easterners, while Queens and the East 20s in Manhattan have most of the Indians. The low West 30s in Midtown Manhattan are Koreatown.
Among non-Hispanic whites, New York's Top 10 specific ethnicities are: Italian, 8.2 percent; Irish, 5.3; German, 3.6; Russian, 3.1; Polish, 2.8; English, 1.9 Greek, 1.0; French, 0.9, Hungarian, 0.7; and Ukrainian, 0.6.
With "urban renewal," most of the old neighborhoods as they would have been known in the days of 3 baseball teams and 1 team each in the other sports are gone. The Irish remain all over. The Belmont section of The Bronx, Ozone Park in Queens, and the Brooklyn neighborhoods of Bay Ridge, Bensonhurst and Dyker Heights are more Italian than Manhattan's Greenwich Village and Little Italy.
Brighton Beach in Brooklyn is Russian and Ukrainian. Greenpoint in Brooklyn is Polish. Astoria in Queens is Balkan, especially Greek and Croatian. And the Lower East Side is a little of everything, but more Eastern Europeans of all varieties than anything else, even if the Hispanics living there call it "Loisaida."
In terms of religion, the City is 23 percent Protestant, 22 percent Catholic, and, surprisingly, only 2 percent Jewish. A whopping 37 percent chose not to tell the Census Bureau. There are still notable Jewish enclaves in Manhattan (the Lower East Side and the Upper East Side), The Bronx (Riverdale), and Brooklyn (Borough Park, more Orthodox and "Old World" than the others).
Going In. To get from either Penn Station or Port Authority to Yankee Stadium, you need to take the Subway. The A and C Trains go to both Penn Station and Port Authority, so take either one to 59th Street-Columbus Circle. Change there, a free transfer, for the D Train.
Or, from both Penn Station and Port Authority, you can walk over to 6th Avenue (a.k.a. Avenue of the Americas, but only the street signs and the Postal Service call it that) and take the D all the way up to 161st Street.
161st Street-River Avenue station on the D Train
The 4 train at the 161st Street elevated station.
This one is heading Downtown after a game.
The Uptown train will be on the other side of the tracks.
Parking decks are on River Avenue at 157th Street, the old deck, across from where the old Stadium was, by the Big Bat; and at 165th Street, north of the new Stadium. I wouldn't recommend driving to the Stadium, though, and don't even ask how much parking is. Take the Subway.
The new Stadium is not as tall as the old Stadium was,
but it covers a lot more ground. And the field is below street level.
There are 4 gates. Gate 2 is at the left field corner, Gate 4 behind home plate, Gate 6 at the right field corner, and Gate 8 in straightaway center field. Your ticket will suggest which gate at which you should enter.
Gate 4, the home plate entrance
Entering by Gate 2 will give you your best shot at seeing Monument Park, but there will already be a long line there, and it closes 45 minutes before first pitch, so you may be out of luck unless you have time to take the Stadium Tour before one of the other games in the series. However, no matter which gate you enter by, you will be able to get to the Yankee Museum, which is open all game long.
About the Stadium Tour: Classic Individual Tours may be purchased for 14 people or less and commence every 20 minutes, primarily from 11:00 AM to 1:40 PM. When these tours sell out, other time slots may become available, from as early as 9:00 AM to as late as 4:40 PM. Buying a ticket online is $20; at the Stadium ticket window or at a Yankees Clubhouse Shop, $25. If you want to add lunch at the Hard Rock Cafe inside The Stadium, it's $40 regardless of where you buy.
The Stadium, like its predecessor, points due east, although it will look like it points northeast on some maps, including the Subway system map, as Manhattan Island is not quite a north-south pointer. The view of the City beyond isn't much, mostly high-rise apartments, many of them housing projects, some of them still classifiable as "tenements" or "slums." (From the old Stadium, a big white building could be seen beyond center field. This is the Bronx County Administration Building, the Borough Hall, including the County Courthouse. But it's not part of the view at the new Stadium.)
Comparing the distances at the various Stadium configurations, as follows: To the left-field line, to straightaway left, to left-center, to straightaway center, to right-center, to straightaway right, to the right-field line:
* 1923-36, the era of Ruth and Gehrig: 285, 395, 460, 520, 425, 350, 295.
* 1937-73, the era of DiMaggio and Mantle: 301, 402, 457, 461, 407, 344 and 296.
* 1976-84, after the major renovation, the era of Jackson: 312, 387, 430, 417, 385, 353 and 310.
* 1985-87, the peak years of Winfield and Mattingly: 312, 379, 411, 410, 385, 353 and 310.
* 1988-present: 318, 379, 399, 408, 385, 353 and 314.
The longest home run at the current Stadium was 477 feet, and was hit by Aaron Judge, on June 11, 2017, off Logan Verett of the Baltimore Orioles, measured at 496 feet.
The longest homer at the old Stadium, unless someone can prove that Babe Ruth hit one longer (and he might have), was by Mickey Mantle, off Ray Herbert of the Chicago White Sox, on August 12, 1964 -- helping to make a winner of Mel Stottlemyre in his major league debut. The length of this homer is in dispute: I've seen it listed as 502 feet and 540. Regardless, Mickey was batting lefthanded, and he hit it to straightaway center -- which would have been in the blacked-out hitters' background in the 1976-2008 configuration, or Monument Park in the current one.
Speaking of configurations, the new Stadium has been used for college football games, including the Pinstripe Bowl since 2010, with the field laid out from home plate to center field. In the old Stadium, which had a lot more field space due to the 461 feet to center field, it was from 1st base to left field.
In 2014, the NHL's Stadium Series gave both the Devils and the Islanders home games at The Stadium against the Rangers, but the Rangers won them both. It's hosted soccer games, and is now in its 4th season as the (allegedly temporary) home of New York City Football Club (NYCFC).
Use the bathrooms before the game. They're big and clean. This is a big difference from the old Stadium, and something the late Yankee owner George Steinbrenner always talked about when he said he wanted a new Stadium. That and more concession stands. Speaking of which...
Food. Because of the prices inside, the traditional recommendation for food at a Yankee game has been to eat outside. Even a recent Thrillist article said so: It said the best thing to eat at Yankee Stadium is a a DWD outside. That's a Dirty Water Dog.
Back in the good old days, the food wasn't great, but at least it was overpriced. This concept should also be familiar to some of you from your home parks. As the team moved into the Nineties and got better, to his credit, George Steinbrenner demanded that the fans get a better food experience. A few specialty stands went up, including a little bakery stand behind home plate on the Main Level. I enjoyed that.
Sadly, that stand didn't make the trip across the street. But chain restaurant stands are there, including Nathan's Hot Dogs, Johnny Rockets, Brother Jimmy's Barbecue, Famiglia Pizzeria, Carvel Ice Cream, and others. There's a Hard Rock Café, and a restaurant called NYY Steak.
(If you want to eat there, assuming you can afford it, you don't have to wear a jacket and tie, but forget about wearing a T-shirt and jeans, and definitely don't wear a team jersey – even a Yankee jersey will be denied entry.)
Inside NYY Steak
Pretty much anything you get will be expensive, but it'll be good. Think of it this way: It would cost the same as movie theater food, but it's better, there's more variety, and the show is better than most movies, and longer, too. Both the show on the field and the show in the stands will be better.
One more thing: If you're using food as a reason why the Mets' gameday experience is better than the Yankees', think again: Although the Mets' food may be tastier on the average, it's every bit as expensive, and the lines are a lot longer. When the Yankees moved from their old Stadium to their new one in 2009, they eliminated long lines; when the Mets did the same, at the same time (meaning they had plenty of time to fix this in the design process), they didn't account for it, and you can still miss an entire inning on line for a milkshake so expensive, even Mia Wallace (Uma Thurman's character in Pulp Fiction) wouldn't go for it.
Team History Displays. No team in all of sports does this better than the Yankees -- as they've told us time and time again. I was at The Stadium for a 2012 preseason match between soccer giants Real Madrid and AC Milan (the Spanish club beat the Italian one, 5-1), and even those clubs don't go on and on about their histories as much as the Yankees do. Then again, Real Madrid have won 12 European Cups, Milan 7, and no other club yet has 6 -- put Madrid's 12 and Milan's 7 together, that's 19, and you still don't come close to having as many "World Championships" as the Yankees.
161st Street outside the Stadium is known as Babe Ruth Plaza, and there are notations on light poles telling the Babe's story. 161st Street east of River Avenue, extending to the Grand Concourse past the Bronx County Courthouse, is Lou Gehrig Plaza. The West Side Highway in Manhattan has been renamed the Joe DiMaggio Highway, but nobody calls it that.
The Great Hall
They also have Thurman Munson's locker from the old Stadium, which was kept empty and waiting for him, as if it were Elijah's cup at a Passover seder. (In the new clubhouse, there's a new empty locker for the 1976-79 Captain.)
Why they gave him a jersey with
the 1947-72 number font is a mystery to me.
One of the club's goals for the Museum is to have baseballs with the autographs of every player who ever played for the Yankees. This might be difficult, considering some of them have been dead for decades, particularly those who played from 1903 to 1920, before the 1st dynasty, and real interest in the Yankees, began. If balls with autographs for the missing players are still in existence, they'll be hard to find.
The Bronze Boss
There is no accompanying display for Yankee pitchers who won the Cy Young Award, which began in 1956: Bob Turley (1958), Whitey Ford (1961), Sparky Lyle (1977), Ron Guidry (1978) and Roger Clemens (2001).
Nor is there one for Yankees who've won the American League's Rookie of the Year: Gil McDougald (1951), Bob Grim (1954), Tony Kubek (1957), Tom Tresh (1962), Stan Bahnsen (1968), Thurman Munson (1970 -- the only Yankee to win both awards), Dave Righetti (1981), Derek Jeter (1996) and Aaron Judge (2017). Lou Piniella (1969), Chris Chambliss (1971), Darryl Strawberry (National League, 1983), Dwight Gooden (NL, 1984), David Justice (NL, 1990), Chuck Knoblauch (1991), Carlos Beltran (1999), Ichiro Suzuki (2001) and Eric Hinske (2002) were notable ROY winners before becoming Yankees. The current NL ROY holder, Cody Bellinger of the Los Angeles Dodgers, is the son of former Yankee Clay Bellinger.
The retired numbers and the World Championships are noted on the walls at the back of the outfield seating -- and the Yankees only mention the 27 World Championships, not Pennants, Division titles or Wild Card berths, like some other teams we could mention.
Retired number display in early 2016,
before the recent additions of Pettitte and Jeter
In Monument Park, there are additional notations for the retired numbers, and the Monuments and the Plaques. It's not as visible from the rest of the Stadium, leading some to call it Monument Cave. But, unlike the old Stadium in its last few years, there is room to add more Plaques.
"Monuments" are meant only for the greatest of the great, and then only after they die. It started in 1932 for Miller Huggins, who won the club's 1st 6 Pennants and its 1st 3 World Series, and died while still Yankee manager in 1929 -- the only Yankee manager to die in office. It was placed on the field, in front of the center field flagpole.
This was not a new innovation, as the New York Giants had already done it at the Polo Grounds for ex-player Eddie Grant, who had been killed in World War I; the monument was lost after they moved to San Francisco. The Pittsburgh Pirates had also placed a monument in center field of Forbes Field for owner Barney Dreyfuss, and moved it to Three Rivers Stadium and now to PNC Park.
Huggins' Monument was joined by Gehrig's in 1941 and Ruth's in 1949. Legend has it that a ball was hit out there one time, and Mantle couldn't catch it, and manager Casey Stengel yelled, "Ruth, Gehrig, Huggins, somebody throw that ball in!" (Most likely, there was a profanity mixed in there.) While this play does not survive on film, there is a surviving 1970 clip of Bobby Murcer letting a ball go off his glove, and it rolled to the wall, and he squeezed between the Huggins and Ruth Monuments to get it.
Plaques for owner Jacob Ruppert and general manager Ed Barrow were placed on the wall of the old Stadium, as were Plaques for DiMaggio and Mantle, and one donated by the local Knights of Columbus to commemorate the 1965 Mass delivered by Pope Paul VI, the 1st Papal Mass ever delivered in the Western Hemisphere. Barrow's Plaque was to the left of the Monuments, the others to the right.
Mantle posing with the Monuments. L to R: Gehrig, Huggins, Ruth.
The Barrow and Ruppert Plaques are on the wall behind him.
When the old Stadium was renovated from 1973 to 1976, the Monuments and Plaques were placed away from the field in the 1st "Monument Park." When Mantle died in 1995, his Plaque was removed the next year and replaced with a Monument. The same was done for DiMaggio early in the 1999 season, shortly after his death.
Monument Park, sometime between 1996 and 2008
A Monument to the 9/11 victims and rescuers was added in 2002, on the 1st anniversary of the attacks; and the one to Steinbrenner was added in 2010 after his death. And, yes, I know, it's too big. Nothing we can do about it now.
* Owners Ruppert and Steinbrenner.
* GM Barrow.
* Catchers Bill Dickey, Yogi Berra, Elston Howard, Thurman Munson and Jorge Posada.
* 1st basemen Don Mattingly and Tino Martinez.
* 2nd basemen Billy Martin (mainly for what he did as a manager) and Willie Randolph.
* Shortstops Phil Rizzuto and Derek Jeter.
* So far, no 3rd basemen or left fielders, although Howard started out as a left fielder, switching positions with Berra in 1960.
* Center fielder Bernie Williams.
* Right fielders Roger Maris, Reggie Jackson and Paul O'Neill.
* Pitchers Lefty Gomez, Red Ruffing, Allie Reynolds, Whitey Ford, Mel Stottlemyre, Ron Guidry, Goose Gossage, Andy Pettitte and Mariano Rivera.
* Managers Joe McCarthy, Casey Stengel, Berra, Martin and Joe Torre.
* Broadcasters Mel Allen, Rizzuto and O'Neill, although O'Neill's broadcasting has, thus far, been incidental to his honoring.
* And public-address announcer Bob Sheppard.
The 3 original Monuments, in front of Big George
There are also Plaques honoring Jackie Robinson, for his role in reintegrating baseball; the civil rights rally held at the old Stadium by Nelson Mandela in 1990; and the Masses delivered by Popes Paul VI in 1965, John Paul II in 1979, and Benedict XVI in 2008.
The 1st 2 Papal Masses led to a dumb joke: "Who are the two Cardinals honored in Yankee Stadium's Monument Park?" The answer is "Miller Huggins and Roger Maris." They both played for the St. Louis Cardinals. Torre and Tino both played for the St. Louis club, so, for the moment, those Cardinals outnumber the Popes 4-3. (Pope Francis has visited New York, but only Madison Square Garden, not Yankee Stadium.)
Copies of the Papal Plaques,
at Knight of Columbus headquarters in New Haven, Connecticut
The retired numbers are: Martin 1, Jeter 2, Ruth 3, Gehrig 4, DiMaggio 5, Torre 6, Mantle 7, 8 for both Dickey and Berra, Maris 9, Rizzuto 10, Munson 15, Ford 16, Posada 20, Mattingly 23, Howard 32, Stengel 37, Rivera 42, Jackson 44, Pettitte 46, Guidry 49 and Williams 51.
This is only part of the display.
Not every player with a Plaque has had his number retired. Gomez wore 11, Ruffing 15 (retired for Munson), Reynolds 22, Stottlemyre and Randolph both 30, and Gossage 54. Huggins died just as uniform numbers were first used, in 1929, and he never wore a number. Nor did McCarthy, even though he was managing in the major leagues as late as 1950.
Why not O'Neill's 21? For that matter, considering his worldwide influence, why not Hideki Matsui's 55? And with performance-enhancing drug controversy having swirled around him again, followed by a new round of "redemption" stories, the question of whether Alex Rodriguez (13) will get his number retired or receive a Plaque appears to be unsettled again -- but Roger Clemens (22) appears to be out of luck.
Strangely, there are Yankees in the Hall of Fame who have not been honored with either a Plaque or a retired number: Pitchers Waite Hoyt, Herb Pennock (both pitched mostly before numbers were worn and did not have a regular number thereafter) and Jim "Catfish" Hunter (29, although the Oakland Athletics retired his 27); 2nd basemen Tony Lazzeri and Joe Gordon (both 6); 3rd baseman Wade Boggs (12, the Tampa Bay Rays retired it for him, and the Red Sox have retired 26 for him), and outfielders Earle Combs (1) and Dave Winfield (31).
Outfielder Enos Slaughter (17) is in the Hall, but is better remembered as a Cardinal (they retired his 9, after Maris and Torre had worn it with them). 1st baseman Johnny Mize (36) is better remembered as a Cardinal (they haven't retired his 10) and a Giant (they haven't retired his 15).
Jerry Coleman (42 long before Rivera) played 2nd base for the Yankees and then broadcast for them, but is in the Hall for his broadcasting for the San Diego Padres, who have given him a retired-number equivalent. And outfielder Rickey Henderson is in the Hall, but since he was probably more hindrance than help in Pinstripes, I don't consider him a "True Yankee." He gets invited to Old-Timers' Day, but he'll never get a Plaque or his Number 24 retired, although the A's have retired that number for him.
Mantle is honored with statues, but in his native Oklahoma rather than New York: Outside a field named for him in his hometown of Commerce, and outside Bricktown Ballpark, home of the Triple-A Oklahoma City Redhawks. That park also has statues of Johnny Bench (the next-greatest ballplayer from Oklahoma) and Warren Spahn (a Buffalo native who married an Oklahoma woman and settled on a farm in the State).
Stengel is honored with 2 statues in the Tri-State Area, but neither is at Yankee Stadium, and I'll get to those later; he's also honored with one at the National Art Museum of Sport in Indianapolis.
Ruth is honored with statues at Camden Yards in his hometown of Baltimore, and at the Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown; DiMaggio at the National Italian-American Sports Hall of Fame in Chicago; Slaughter at Busch Stadium in St. Louis; Coleman at Petco Park in San Diego; and Cory Lidle, who was a Yankee when he was killed in a 2006 plane crash, has a statue at Big League Dreams Sports Park in his hometown of West Covina, California.
In 1933, the 1st All-Star Game was held. Ruth, Gehrig, Lazzeri, Dickey, Gomez and Ben Chapman (we don't like to talk about him, due to how he treated Jackie Robinson as Philadelphia Phillies manager in 1947) were the Yankees named to the American League team.
In 1969, in commemoration of the 100th Anniversary of professional baseball, an All-Time Team was selected. Ruth was selected as the Greatest Player Ever, DiMaggio as the Greatest Living Player (a conceit he insisted upon being introduced as for the rest of his life), and Gehrig was named the team's 1st baseman.
They, Mantle and Berra were named to the Major League Baseball All-Century Team in 1999, as was the still-active and newly-acquired Clemens. That same year, all of those, plus Dickey, Gomez, Ford, Jackson, Winfield and Boggs were named to The Sporting News' 100 Greatest Baseball Players. In 2006, Yankee Fans chose Ruth in the poll for DHL Hometown Heroes.
There is no trophy for the winner of the season series between the Yankees and the Red Sox. The Yankees have won it 66 times, the Red Sox 37, and there have been 12 splits. Counting the postseason, the Yankees lead in games, 1,201-1,018.
Stuff. There are souvenir stands all over the place, and large souvenir stores on both the 1st-base and 3rd-base sides of the Stadium's lower level. Essentially, if you want it, and if you can afford it, you can get it. It's fun to look at, and to watch other people go nuts over it.
There are 5 Yankees Clubhouse Shops, all in Midtown Manhattan: 245 West 42nd Street (between Port Authority and Times Square), 1501 Broadway (at 50th Street), 745 7th Avenue (at 51st Street), 393 5th Avenue (at 37th Street, between the main Public Library and the Empire State Building), and 110 East 59th Street (east of Central Park). Not only do these Clubhouse Shops sell Yankee gear, but you can buy game tickets there.
There was one at the Pier 17 shopping mall at the South Street Seaport in Lower Manhattan, but that complex was flooded by Hurricane Sandy, and was demolished and rebuilt, as yet without a Clubhouse Shop.
Regardless of where you shop, I don't mind if you get one of those floppy, fake-fur, star-spangled top hats that resemble the one in the Yankee logo. But, please, if you're going to buy a Yankee cap, make it a real Yankee cap: Navy blue with a white interlocking N-Y.
Wearing the patriotic-holiday caps with the Stars & Stripes N-Y is fine. But the Yankees do not wear red caps, green caps, yellow caps, or, God forbid, pink caps. If you're a woman who loves the Yankees, respect them enough to get the real thing, not a pink one. And for crying out loud, don't leave the stickers on. And curve the brim, why doncha?
This is not okay -- on 2 levels.
There have been more books written about the Yankees than any other team. The best single-volume history of the team is Pinstripe Empire by Marty Appel, once the team's publicity director, covering the team from its 1903 beginning through the 2011 season, and he didn't avoid controversy when writing it.
Good books about individual Yankee seasons include:
* 1923, about the building of the old Stadium and the 1st title: The House That Ruth Built by Robert Weintraub.
* 1927, Murderer's Row: Five O'Clock Lightning by travel expert and Yankee Fan Harvey Frommer.
* 1932, including the most Ruthian moment of them all: Babe Ruth's Called Shot: The Myth and Mystery of Baseball's Greatest Home Run, by Ed Sherman.
* 1939: A Legend in the Making: The New York Yankees in 1939 by Richard Tofel.
* 1941, including DiMaggio's streak and many other items about baseball that season: Baseball in '41 by Robert Creamer. He also wrote Babe: The Legend Comes to Life (which doesn't avoid the Bambino's dark side, and,unfortunately, repeats a lot of the since-debunked stories) and Stengel: His Life and Times (considerably better, and reveals the genius behind the clown).
* 1947, including the 1st televised World Series, inspiring the phrase that became the book's title: Electric October: Seven World Series Games, Six Lives, Five Minutes of Fame That Lasted Forever, by Kevin Cook.
* 1949, the arrival of Stengel, and the beginning of a new Dynasty: Summer of '49 by David Halberstam.
* 1956, Mantle's memoir of his Triple Crown season, including the Don Larsen perfect game that he saved with both a home run and a great catch, My Favorite Summer 1956.
* 1961, including the Mantle & Maris home run record chase: 1961*: The Inside Story of the Maris-Mantle Home Run Chase by Phil Pepe of the Daily News. Shortstop Tony Kubek and manager Ralph Houk also wrote memoirs of that season.
* 1964, the end of the old Dynasty: October 1964, also by Halberstam.
* 1977, telling the story of mid-1970s New York City as a whole, including the Son of Sam case and the 1977 Mayor's race: Ladies and Gentlemen, The Bronx Is Burning by Jonathan Mahler. Steve Jacobson of Newsday wrote The Best Team Money Could Buy right after that season.
* 1977 and 1978, including the George-Billy-Reggie triangle of controversy: October Men by Roger Kahn.
* 1996, the return to glory: Birth of a Dynasty by Joel Sherman of the New York Post.
* 2001, that Dynasty's end: The Last Night of the Yankee Dynasty, by Buster Olney.
* 2009, the transition to the new Stadium and Title 27: The Ghosts of 161st Street, by David J. Joyce.
Peter Golenbock's Dynasty is about the entire era bracketed by Halberstam's books, and Dog Days by Philip Bashe tells of the dark age between 1964 and 1976 (with those seasons included).
Memoirs by Yankees, especially those written prior to Jim Bouton's 1970 Ball Four, should be taken with a grain of salt, some of them with an entire salt mine. But there are many good recent biographies of individual Yankees: Leigh Montville's The Big Bam (Ruth -- Montville's books about Boston sports legends Ted Williams and Bobby Orr are also excellent), Ray Robinson's Iron Horse: Lou Gehrig in His Time, Tom Clavin and Danny Peary's Roger Maris: Reluctant Hero, and local sportswriter Ian O'Connor's The Captain: The Journey of Derek Jeter.
Books about DiMaggio were nearly all laudatory during his life, but since his death, without him able to sic his lawyers on authors, some rough ones have come out. Electric October makes him look bad, but the real warts-and-all story is Richard Ben Cramer's Joe DiMaggio: The Hero's Life.
You soon wonder why a guy like that was ever treated as a hero, but Cramer answers that question, and his answer says as much about America from Joe D's rookie year of 1936 until his death in 1999 as it does about Joe D himself. As one reviewer put it, the answer to Paul Simon's musical question, "Where have you gone, Joe DiMaggio? A nation turns its lonely eyes to you" was, "The guy you turned your lonely eyes to wasn't really there: He was a fake, the lie spread by Joe himself as much as by the media." It's unquestionably the best-researched book on the Yankee Clipper.
The best bio of Mantle is probably the dual story Mickey and Willie, which Allen Barra wrote about Mantle and Mays. Barra also wrote the best bio of Berra (no relation): Yogi Berra: Eternal Yankee.
Marty Appel's Munson: The Life and Death of a Yankee Captain is terrific, but difficult, especially if you're old enough to have watched and revered Thurman: Appel devoted an entire chapter to the day of the crash, and another to the day of the funeral, including the epic game the Yankees played that night.
Golenbock wrote Number 1 with Billy Martin, but also Wild, High and Tight: The Life and Death of Billy Martin, which, with some fairness, made Billy look like a monster rather than, as Bill Pennington put it in his recent bio, Billy Martin: Baseball's Flawed Genius. Golenbock also ghost-wrote The Bronx Zoo with Sparky Lyle and Balls with Graig Nettles, but went too far with 7: The Mickey Mantle Novel. (His oral histories of the Mets, Red Sox, Cubs, Cardinals and Brooklyn Dodgers are all excellent.)
Dayn Perry wrote Reggie Jackson: The Life and Thunderous Career of Baseball's Mr. October, and while it does a good job of explaining him, it doesn't make him look good. In response to that book and the 2007 ESPN miniseries version of The Bronx Is Burning, both of which he thought portrayed him unfairly, Reggie wrote Becoming Mr. October. And completing the tangled triumverate of George-Billy-Reggie, Bill Madden of the Daily News wrote Steinbrenner: The Last Lion of Baseball -- which came out right before George died, and had to have an afterword for when it came out in paperback.
In addition to all the books about the Yankees, there's lots and lots of DVDs, including the World Series highlight film collection (starting in 1943 when official Series highlight films began, and running through 2000, with 2009 having been released after that), the 1996-2001 Fall Classic Collectors Edition, YES Network Yankeeography collections, and The Essential Games of Yankee Stadium.
The last of these was released as the old Stadium closed, and, with the video library seriously limited due to TV stations taping over a lot of broadcasts to save money on videotape, there's nothing from the pre-renovation Stadium. The 6 games included are: 1976 ALCS Game 5 (the Chris Chambliss Game), 1977 World Series Game 6 (Reggie becomes Mr. October), 1995 ALDS Game 2 (Jim Leyritz's walkoff homer in the 15th inning), 1996 World Series Game 6 (ending an 18-year drought), 2001 World Series Game 4 (Jeter's walkoff), and 2003 ALCS Game 7 (the Aaron Boone Game).
There are lots of movies about the Yankees, and they run from very good to dreadful. Avoid any movie about Ruth: The Babe Ruth Story (1948, played by William Bendix), Babe Ruth (1991, Stephen Lang), The Babe (John Goodman, perhaps the only actor who had to lose weight to play the Bambino), and Everyone's Hero (2006 cartoon, voiced by Brian Dennehy).
In contrast, The Pride of the Yankees (1942), the film about Lou Gehrig (Gary Cooper), is very good, if full of the sappy sentimentality of the World War II years -- and Ruth, Bill Dickey, Bob Meusel and Mark Koenig, as well as one of that era's top sportscasters, Bill Stern, play themselves. Teresa Wright played Lou's wife Eleanor. In 1978, her memoir was turned into the TV-movie A Love Affair: The Eleanor and Lou Gehrig Story, starring Blythe Danner and Edward Herrmann. It was a bit more honest, but Lou was such a good guy, the only shocking thing in it is that Lou and his mother didn't always get along. (Ramon Bieri played Ruth.)
There is, as yet, no movie about the DiMaggio Era Yankees, although PBS made a documentary out of Richard Ben Cramer's book, narrated by Cramer, for their American Experience series. Mantle and Maris played each other in Safe at Home (avoid it, it stinks), while they and Berra had a brief scene in the Yankee dugout with Cary Grant and Doris Day in That Touch of Mink (which is a light romantic comedy and not at all about baseball, so if that's what you're looking for, avoid it). Paul Sorvino starred in a film based on Torre's post-1996 memoir Chasing the Dream (a nice try, but avoid it).
Billy Crystal filmed 61* about the home run chase by Mantle (Thomas Jane) and Maris (Barry Pepper). His daughter Jennifer Crystal Foley played Pat Maris, and Renee Taylor (Fran's mother on The Nanny) was hilarious as Claire Ruth. With CGI adding the 3rd deck, Tiger Stadium in Detroit stood in for the pre-renovation old Yankee Stadium, while the Los Angeles Coliseum stood in for Baltimore's Memorial Stadium. ESPN turned Mahler's book into the miniseries The Bronx Is Burning, and Dodd Stadium in Norwich, Connecticut (then home to a Yankee farm team), with CGI, stood in for all the ballparks.
61* had Michael Nouri as DiMaggio, Christopher McDonald as Mel Allen, and Joe Grifasi as Rizzuto. The Bronx Is Burning had McDonald as DiMaggio, Grifasi as Berra, and Rizzuto's preserved broadcasts. Both used Bob Sheppard, the former with him doing voiceovers to simulate his 1961 announcing, the latter using his recordings from 1977. In The Bronx Is Burning, Steinbrenner was played by Oliver Platt, Martin by John Turturro, Jackson by Daniel Sunjata, and Stephen Lang shows up again, as Tim Dowd, who led the NYPD task force pursuing the Son of Sam.
During the Game. A recent Thrillist article ranked Yankee Fans as the 4th "most intolerable" in MLB, citing Edward Norton's profane cursing out of every ethnic group in New York City to his mirror in The 25th Hour, calling us "basically the Bensonhurst Italian section of that scene, times a thousand. No fanbase on Earth is more arrogant, more entitled, more cocky, and more horrible than the Yankees."
Arrogant? Entitled? Cocky? Horrible? Jeez, pal, those are some of our strong points!
All kidding aside: If you plan to wear opposing team gear into Yankee Stadium -- especially Red Sox or Mets -- I strongly recommend before starting out, including before ordering the tickets online or over the phone, that you find friends to go with you, so that you can go in numbers. At least 4. That'll make it less likely that Yankee Fans will give you anything more than verbal abuse. Chances are, nobody will take a swing at you or push you. But the ones who might want to will be far less likely to go after more than one Sox or Met fan.
And the further you get from the Bleachers, the likelier it will be that you will avoid violence. The security force, including actual NYPD officers, will eject anyone who fights -- if they catch them in the act, that is. The fans know this, and most will not be so drunk that they won't care about getting tossed, arrested, jailed for a night, and forced to show up in court, where they will inevitably lose their case, and get fined and publicly humiliated. The vast majority who will remain completely (or mostly) sober will care about such treatment, and will not do anything that will invite that risk. New Yorkers (and New Jerseyans) can be nasty, but most of us are not that stupid.
(Be advised, though, that most of the cast of the TV show Jersey Shore was actually from New York City or New York State - and, yes, they are that stupid.)
Chances are, this guy in the middle got kicked out.
Smoking is no longer allowed in Yankee Stadium.
From 1969 until 2003, Brooklyn-born opera singer Robert Merrill sang the National Anthem at Yankee games. Occasionally, they still use his recording of it. But they no longer have a regular anthem singer. Like Merrill, Eddie Layton, organist from 1967, also served through 2003, and, like Merrill, died in 2004. In his 1st season, Layton invented "DUM dum dum dum DUM dum dum dum... " But he was not, as many believe, the inventor of "Da da da DAT da DA... CHARGE!" That was USC football placekicker and band trumpeter Tommy Walker, in 1947.
Bob Sheppard became the public-address announcer for the Yankees in 1951 and, when they moved to Yankee Stadium, the football Giants in 1956, and remained with the Giants through 1996 and the Yankees through 2007. The man played quarterback, and later taught speech, at St. John's University in Queens.
"Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen,
and welcome to Yankee Stadium."
His words, "Your attention please, ladies and gentlemen... " would ring out through The Stadium many times a game. He hated announcers like Bob Casey of the Minnesota Twins and Ray Clay of the Chicago Bulls, who made a spectacle of their own announcements. Rather, he believed in what he called the 3 C's: Being clear, concise, and correct. Whenever a new player came to the team, he made sure he met the man, and, if he had the slightest doubt, asked the player how he pronounced the name.
He said he liked Hispanic and Japanese names, because of the vowels, citing 1980s Yankee shortstop Alvaro Espinoza and 2000s Seattle Mariner reliever Shigetoshi Hasegawa as favorites. He didn't like hard consonants, saying, "What am I going to do with 'Mickey Klutts'?" Nevertheless, he said his favorite name to say was, "Mickey Mantle." Mantle said, "When he announced my name, I got goose bumps." Told this, Sheppard said, "So did I."
Jeter liked his introduction so much that he asked him to record one for him -- taking into account the possibility, never realized, that Jeter would one day play a position other than shortstop: "Now batting for the Yankees, Number 2, Derek Jeter, Number 2." It introduced Jeter until his retirement in 2014, 4 years after Sheppard's death, a few weeks short of turning 100.
Former Yankees and Cleveland Indians broadcaster Paul Olden is now the P.A. announcer. He doesn't sound like Sheppard, but uses the same style. For a player's 1st at-bat, he, like Sheppard, announces the uniform number, the name, the position, and the number again: "Number 44... Reggie Jackson... right field... Number 44." (Reggie called Sheppard "the Voice of God.") For each subsequent at-bat, it is the position and the name: "The center fielder... Bernie Williams."
The Yankees have a theme song, "Here Come the Yankees," introduced in 1967 as a counterpoint to "Meet the Mets." This is one area (along with food and parking) where the Mets have a clear advantage. It's still played before and after every Yankee radio broadcast. It sounds a lot better without the lyrics.
In the top of the 1st inning, the Bleacher Creatures, who sat in Sections 37 and 39 of the old Stadium and moved to roughly the same spot, Section 203, in the new one, will begin their "Roll Call." They will chant each starting player's name or nickname until the player waves back to them. They always start with the center fielder.
They will also salute broadcasters John Sterling and Michael Kay, who used to do the games together on WABC 770 AM radio. Now Sterling is on WFAN 660 AM with Suzyn Waldman, and Kay is on YES Network TV with various partners, including (depending on the night) Yankee legends David Cone and Paul O'Neill, and former Baltimore Orioles star Ken Singleton, a New York native. (Singleton has announced that he is retiring after this season.)
The Yankees do not have a mascot. They tried one once, calling him Dandy (after the song "Yankee Doodle Dandy"). After consulting with the company that made the Phillie Phanatic's costume, the Yankees were ready to introduce Dandy late in the 1979 season. Then Munson was killed, and it was decided that Dandy, who had a big bushy mustache, looked too much like Munson (others said he more closely resembled recently-traded pitcher Sparky Lyle), so he was shelved.
He was introduced at Opening Day in 1980, but the fans, for reasons that probably had nothing to do with Munson, reacted badly to him, even punching him. The guy in the suit was a college kid trying to make a few extra bucks, and his mother complained to Yankee management and made him quit. That was the end of Dandy.
Yes, Dandy actually existed.
Throughout the game, the big video boards will have tributes to various figures from the Yankees' past. When the Yankees score -- any run, not just on a home run -- just after the runner crosses the plate, a very loud version of the Westminster Chimes are played. "DING-dong-DING-dong... Bomp-BOMP-bomp-BOMMMMP!" This is one of those things that Yankee Haters find very annoying about the team, or should.
On clips of old Yankee games (such as on YES' Yankees Classics), you might hear somebody banging a spoon on a metal pan. This was Freddy Schuman. An elderly Bronx native, who lost an eye decades ago, he walked through the stands banging a spoon on a metal pan, and carrying a sign attached to the pan, with a message-of-the-day, always beginning with the words “FREDDY SEZ.” Yankee Fans were very loyal to him and protective of him. He was such a beloved figure that he was invited to ride on a float in each of the Yankees' last 5 World Championship victory parades. Sadly, you won't see him now: Like Steinbrenner and Sheppard, Freddy died in 2010. He was 85.
The Great City Subway Race." This is a variation on the Milwaukee Brewers' "Sausage Race," except it's totally on the board, no people in costumes on the field. Choose which train will get to The Stadium first: B, D or 4. You don't get anything if you pick the right train, though. (The B only goes to Yankee Stadium during evening rush hours, and away from it, into Midtown Manhattan, during the morning rush, which is why I recommend taking the A to the D to get to The Stadium, or taking the 4 if you have an East Side hotel.)
The grounds crew will drop their rakes and drag-cages to spell out Y-M-C-A with the fans.
It's stupid -- as Chicago White Sox fans taught us, disco sucks -- and it's not even a particularly old "Yankee Tradition," having been started in 1996. But the Yanks won the Series that year, for the 1st time in 18 years (I know, doesn't seem like a long time to most of you), since the song was new (1978), and, well, you know how superstitious baseball people can get.
It used to get worse -- much worse, in terms of both physical pressure and style. If you needed any more reasons to not wear opposing team gear in the Yankee Stadium Bleachers, at this stage of the game, the Bleacher Creatures would have already found someone wearing "enemy colors," and as "YMCA" began to be played, a few of them would surround him, insuring that he couldn't get away, while the rest clapped along. They didn't touch him, so they couldn't be charged with assault, but this was true harassment, and the cops in the section didn't seem to give a damn. The Creatures made up their own words to this song, and instead of "YMCA," they sang "Why Are You Gay?"
The adjusted lyrics are too vile to be printed here: Even though this blog occasionally includes some nasty profanities, this entry is for guests of our City and our team, and, in the interest of courtesy, I won't go that far on this occasion. They can be found on YouTube, if you dare, but I won't post a clip.
After a series of events in October 2010, before and during the Playoffs, Yankee Stadium security announced the variation song would no longer be tolerated. Sure, it was funny -- until you imagine what might have happened if the "victim" tried to fight back. And, I'm sure, a few of the fans who got this treatment might actually have been gay, and this must have been horrible for them, especially if they were still closeted. But then, if they were stupid enough to wear an opposing team's gear into that Stadium, into that section, then it's hard to sympathize with them for getting some kind of poor treatment, regardless of their orientation. (Most of the Bleacher Creatures are Irish, Italian and Hispanic, and thus Catholic, and have had it drilled into their minds from the time of puberty that being gay is a mortal sin.)
During the 7th inning stretch, a moment of silence for American troops will be, uh, requested. Then "God Bless America" will be played, usually Kate Smith's legendary 1938 recording, although sometimes there will be a live singer. Compared to that, the follow-up of "Take Me Out to the Ballgame" will be relatively muted.
During the middle of the 8th inning, the Yankees do something worse than the Orioles, in their own tough, gritty, Northeastern city, do when they play John Denver's "Thank God I'm a Country Boy." They play "Cotton Eye Joe" by Rednexx, and from the control room behind home plate, a yutz named Cotton Eye Joey, wearing overalls and a straw hat, will be shown on the video board doing a stupid dance. (Like Milwaukee's original Bernie Brewer, the original Cotton Eye Joe portrayer was fired for showing up drunk, so they got "Joey" to replace him.) They periodically break away to show fans dancing along.
Why this stupid song is played in New York City, of all places, I don’t know. Suddenly, Boston's playing of "Sweet Caroline" doesn't sound nearly so cheesy, does it?
In 1978, Ron Guidry set a Yankee record that still stands (and a former AL record for lefthanded pitchers) with 18 strikeouts in a game, against the California Angels. That game began the tradition of fans standing up and clapping on a two-strike pitch. It gets especially intense when it's the potential last out of the game. Met fans claim they started this tradition with Dwight Gooden in 1984, but we have the video evidence showing that, as usual, Met fans are full of baloney.
Met fans did, however, at that time, invent the "K-Korner," although Yankee Fans took it to a new level in the 1990s; but such cutesy stuff as traffic cones or ice cream cones for David Cone, beer mugs for David Wells, rockets for Roger Clemens, pictures of John "the Duke" Wayne for Orlando "El Duque" Hernandez and Bullwinkles for Mike "Moose" Mussina have long since gone by the boards.
On May 22, 2017, in honor of new star Aaron Judge, who plays (but, batting righthanded, usually does not hit to) right field, the Yankees debuted "The Judge's Chambers." It's a 3-row section, a total of 18 seats, in Section 104 of the right field Bleachers, not far behind Judge's spot in the outfield, with faux mahogany wood. The fans who have season tickets there wear black robes like judges, but with the Yankee Interlocking NY on them, and carry foam gavels.
If the Yankees win, they will play a recording of broadcaster John Sterling giving his signature radio call: "Ballgame over! Yankees win! The-e-e-e-e-e-e… Yankees win!" If you look in the press box – you may need binoculars for this – you can see Sterling in the WFAN radio booth, doing "the Sterling Shake" when he actually says it. (At the time of that clip, the Yankees were on WCBS, 880 AM.)
At least, if you don't bring a radio, you won't have to hear his home run call: "It is high! It is far! It is... GONE!" Which, all too often, ends up as, "It is... a foul ball!" Or "It is... caught at the wall!" I hate it when he does that. Like Mel Allen in the Yankees' most glorious era, Sterling tends to watch the ball. Red Barber, who broadcast for the Brooklyn Dodgers at that time, and later switched to the Yankees, taught people to watch the outfielder, to see if he thinks he can catch it, so you'll have a better idea if he can catch it. Sterling doesn't do this.
Sterling also makes up some really whacked-out calls for individual players. The best-known is, "It's an A-bomb from A-Rod!" (I always wondered what Japanese Yankee Hideki Matsui thought about that one.)
Between Sterling, Waldman ("Oh my good, goodness gracious!" for Clemens' ill-fated 2007 comeback), and Kay (infamous for "The Curse of Kay," citing an overwhelming stat which gets reversed in that very at-bat), I don't think there's any fans in all of sports who dislike their own broadcasters as much as Yankee Fans do. They're all decent people, but they're damn near impossible to listen to.
It used to be that, if the Yankees won, Frank Sinatra's 1980 version of "Theme From New York, New York" would play over the P.A. system; and, when they lost, they would play Liza Minnelli's version – which, everybody forgets, is the original version, coming from the 1977 movie in which Liza plays a 1940s Big Band singer and Robert DeNiro her saxophonist husband. Liza found out about being linked with losing games and objected, and the Yankee brass did something they almost never do: They caved in. After all, Liza, like the Yankees, is a New York icon, just as Sinatra was. Now, Frank's version plays, win or lose.
Oddly, the Mets sometimes play Liza's version at Citi Field, especially since she sang it live at Shea Stadium in 2001, when the Mets played the first sporting event in the City after the 9/11 attacks. But their game-closing song is "New York State of Mind" by Billy Joel, who played the last concert at Shea, even though he's a Yankee Fan who was the first soloist to play the old Stadium other than as a postgame show. (The Isley Brothers and the Newport Jazz Festival preceded him, and the Beach Boys had played a couple of postgame concerts.).
Now that pitcher A.J. Burnett is gone, there is no more "walkoff pie." In 2009, when he arrived, and the Yankees got a walkoff hit, the player who got it was almost immediately corralled by Kim Jones of the YES Network, and, in mid-interview, he got hit in the face with a shaving-cream pie by pitcher A.J. Burnett. If the Yanks went to the bottom of the 9th tied or trailing by a run, a fan brought out a banner reading, "WE WANT PIE." But with Burnett gone, no one took up the, uh, mantle, and this relatively new "Yankee Tradition" went the way of multipurpose concrete oval stadiums and pinstriped bullpen cars.
After the Game. Win or lose, I would advise against going to one of the bars across River Avenue from The Stadium. Forget Billy's, Stan's, the Yankee Tavern, the Yankee Eatery and the rest. Regardless of whether they won or lost, the people there do not want to see opposing fans. The best thing you can do is head for your car or the Subway (depending on how you got there), and get out as quickly and as quietly as you safely can.
If you're staying for more than just the one day, there will be plenty of time to take in a famous New York restaurant other than after the game. I would suggest staying away from really big names like the major steakhouses (Smith & Wollensky's, Gallagher's, Peter Luger's, Delmonico's, Del Frisco's, Morton's), because of the insane prices and the need for reservations.
Don't bother with the 21 Club, despite its featuring in The Bronx Is Burning: Reggie was right, it's no big deal, except when you get the check. Also stay away from the Russian Tea Room, next-door to Carnegie Hall: It's not only really expensive, but the food is rather ordinary. And the legendary delis on 7th Avenue in Midtown are both gone forever: The Stage closed in 2012 and the Carnegie in 2016.
New York pushcart hot dogs and pretzels? Believe it or not, they are cheap (usually $2.50), far more sanitary than legend would suggest, and occasionally tasty. I've had really good ones, really bad ones, and everything in between. But, chances are, you'll get a good one at a big bargain.
If you're a fan of a visiting American League team, these bars have been known to cater to fans from the cities/metro areas in question:
* Baltimore Orioles: HorseBox, 218 Avenue A. L Train to 1st Avenue.
* Boston Red Sox: Professor Thom's, 219 2nd Avenue. L Train to 3rd Avenue.
* Chicago White Sox: Canal Bar, 270 3rd Avenue – the only one of these in Brooklyn. R Train to Union Street.
* Cleveland Indians: Manny's On Second, 1770 2nd Avenue. Q Train to 86th Street.
* Detroit Tigers: Mercury Bar East, 493 3rd Avenue. 6 Train to 33rd Street. Warning: They don't let in anybody wearing jeans.
* Houston Astros: Hill Country Barbecue, 30 W. 26th Street. N or R Train to 28th Street.
* Kansas City Royals: Village Pourhouse, 64 3rd Avenue. L Train to 3rd Avenue.
* Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim: Unknown. Fans of other L.A. area teams meet at Taqueria St. Mark's Place, 79 St. Mark's Place. 6 Train to Astor Place. Be advised, though, that these may include Dodger fans.* Minnesota Twins: Bar None, 98 3rd Avenue. L Train to 3rd Avenue.
* Oakland Athletics: Finnerty's, 221 2nd Avenue. L Train to 3rd Avenue. Be advised, though, that this is a bar for all the Bay Area teams, and there may also be Giants fans here.
* Seattle Mariners: Carlow East, 1254 Lexington Avenue. 4, 5 or 6 Train to 86th Street.
* Tampa Bay Rays: Stillwater, 78 E. 4th Street. F Train to 2nd Avenue.
* Texas Rangers: Stone Creek, 140 E. 27th Street. 6 Train to 28th Street.
* Toronto Blue Jays: Van Diemen's, 383 3rd Avenue. 6 Train to 28th Street.
If you're visiting New York during the European soccer season, as we are now in, there are many places where you can watch your favorite team. The best "football pub" in The City, and, indeed, in the country, is The Football Factory, downstairs at Legends NYC, at 6 West 33rd Street, across from the Empire State Building, and 2 blocks east from The Garden. B, D, F, N, Q or R train to 34th Street-Herald Square. The downside is that, for Premier League games, it gets crowded quickly.
Sports Sidelights. If you have time to look around New York, and are interested in other baseball-related sites, read on. If not, skip to the end of this article. I won't mind, but you may be sorry you missed these:
Judging by the scoreboard and the exterior,
this picture was taken sometime between 1959 and 1966.
Judging by the scoreboard, this picture
was taken sometime between 1950 and 1958.
Looks like between 1967 and 1973.
Sometime from 2001 to 2008.
There were 13 fights for the Heavyweight Championship of the World there. This does not count Jack Dempsey knocking out future champ Jack Sharkey on July 21, 1927, in between his 2 title fight defeats to Gene Tunney. Nor does it include the 1st fight between Max Schmeling, then the former champ, and Joe Louis, not yet the champ, on June 19, 1936. Louis had been 24-0, and would eventually rise to 58-1.
It does count the time Tunney knocked Tom Heeney out on July 26, 1928, and then retired. That vacancy was awarded to Schmeling on December 6, 1930, when Jack Sharkey hit him with a low blow and was disqualified.
After winning the title at Comiskey Park in Chicago, Louis defended his title at Yankee Stadium 7 times: A a decision over Tommy Farr on August 30, 1937; avenging his previous to Schmeling in an amazing 1st-round knockout on June 22, 1938, striking a blow against prejudice both at home and abroad; getting up from a surprising knockdown to knock out fat Bronx bartender "Two Ton" Tony Galento on June 28, 1939; knocking Arturo Godoy out on June 20, 1940; knocking Billy Conn out on June 19, 1946; knocking Tami Mauriello out on September 18, 1946; and avenging his controversial decision win over Jersey Joe Walcott at Madison Square Garden, knocking him out on June 25, 1948.
The next champion was Ezzard Charles, and he knocked Gus Lesnevich out at The Stadium on August 10, 1949. Rocky Marciano knocked Charles out there twice in 1954, on June 17 and September 17, a fight he nearly lost. He then survived a brutal fight with Light Heavyweight Champion Archie Moore, knocking him out on September 21, 1955, and then retired.
Ingemar Johansson took the title from Floyd Patterson with a stunning knockout on June 26, 1959. And, in the only professional fight at the old Stadium after its renovation, Muhammad Ali kept the title with a controversial decision over Ken Norton on September 28, 1976.
Joe Louis vs. Billy Conn, 1946,
a rematch of their 1941 fight at the Polo Grounds.
The old Stadium hosted some legendary soccer games, including visits by Glasgow's Celtic, both AC Milan and their city rivals Internazionale, Portuguese giants Benfica, and a 1952 match between the last 2 champions of England's Football League, with Tottenham of North London clobbering Manchester United. The New York Cosmos of the original North American Soccer League played their 1971 and 1976 seasons there.
Yankee Stadium: Home of Ruth, Gehrig, DiMaggio, Mantle,
Louis, Marciano, Rockne, Gifford... and Pelé.
* Citi Field and the site of Shea Stadium. Almost certainly, when one New York MLB team is at home, the other is on the road. The Mets do offer tours of their new ballpark, with its exterior reminiscent of Ebbets Field. Citi Field was built next-door to the William A. Shea Municipal Stadium, since demolished. (Shea was a lawyer who spearheaded the drive to get the National League put an expansion team in New York after the Giants and Dodgers left.)
The Mets played there from 1964 to 2008; the Yankees in 1974 and '75 while the old Yankee Stadium was being renovated; the AFL/NFL's Jets from 1964 to 1983; the NFL's Giants in 1975; and the Beatles on August 15, 1965 and August 23, 1966.
Shea Stadium in 1974 and 1975.
The Yankee logo can be seen atop the old scoreboard,
where the Met logo would usually be.
The home plate entrance to Citi Field includes the original Home Run Apple from Shea (replaced on the inside), and the Jackie Robinson Rotunda, acting as a sort of "Presidential Library" for the man who reintegrated baseball. Ironically, I can find no evidence that Jackie ever even visited Shea Stadium.
To the right of the entrance is the Mets Hall of Fame, with their own "Monument Park" type setup, their 1969 and 1986 World Series trophies, seats from the Polo Grounds and Shea, and a statue of Casey Stengel.
Citi Field has not yet hosted American football, but it's hosted some soccer games, including a game last season when the Playoffs bumped NYCFC -- who also had to move a game to East Hartford, Connecticut when a rainout makeup bumped them from Yankee Stadium II.
126th Street & Roosevelt Avenue, in the Flushing Meadow section of Queens. Take the Number 7 train to "Mets-Willets Point" station.
* The Billie Jean King National Tennis Center. It's across Roosevelt Avenue from Citi Field, in Flushing Meadow-Corona Park, site of the 1939-40 and 1964-65 New York World's Fairs. A few things remain from the '64 Fair, including the Unisphere globe (which you might remember being destroyed in the film Men In Black), but the only thing that remains from the 1939 fair is the Queens Museum of Art, which contains exhibits about both fairs, including "The Panorama of New York City," a scale model of the City that was updated until 1992 – in other words, it doesn't show the newer skyscrapers, and it still shows the old World Trade Center. This building was also the first home of the United Nations, from 1946 to 1950.
The U.S. Open has been held at Flushing Meadow every late August and early September since 1978, with the opening of Louis Armstrong Stadium. (The legendary jazzman lived in nearby Corona, and his house is now a museum. He was a Yankee season-ticket holder and, surprisingly for a black man of his time, a big tennis fan.) Prior to that, the Open was held from 1915 to 1977 at the 14,000-seat Forest Hills Stadium (which also hosted the Beatles on August 28 & 29, 1964 – 69th Avenue & Burns Street, E, F, M or R Train to 71st Avenue-Continental Avenue). Since 1997, with the opening of the Arthur Ashe Stadium, Armstrong Stadium has been the tournament's secondary facility.
* Site of Hilltop Park. Definitely not a place to visit at night. The Yankees' 1st home was at the highest point on Manhattan Island, hence the club's original name, the New York Highlanders, and the name of the stadium, Hilltop Park.
It wasn't much: A 14,000-seat wood and concrete structure at 165th Street & Broadway. They played there from their 1903 debut until 1912. When the Polo Grounds burned down in 1911, the Yankees let the Giants play there until a new Polo Grounds could be built. The Yankees finished 2nd at Hilltop Park in 1904, 1906 and 1910, but never won the Pennant, and only the 1904 race was especially close.
In 1993, a plaque was unveiled at roughly the spot where home plate was. An honored guest was Chet "Red" Hoff, who made his major league debut with the Highlanders at Hilltop in 1911. A pitcher, the 1st batter he faced was Ty Cobb, and he struck him out. Hoff was 102 years old at the time of the dedication, and lived to be 107, the oldest former MLB player ever. Take the A train to 168th Street.
* Site of the Polo Grounds. Also not a place to visit at night, but definitely a place to visit in daylight if you're a baseball fan. There were 2 stadiums built on the site: The 1st in 1890 and burned down in 1911, the 2nd built immediately afterward and torn down in 1964.
The baseball Giants played here from 1890 to 1957, the football Giants from 1925 to 1955, the Yankees from 1913 to 1922, the Mets in 1962 and '63, and the AFL's Titans (forerunners of the Jets) from 1960 to 1963.
The Polo Grounds, as it would have looked
during the Yankees' tenure there, 1913 to 1922
It also hosted some legendary college football games, including the 1924 Army-Notre Dame game where sportswriter Grantland Rice named the Notre Dame backfield "the Four Horsemen," and the 1937 duel between Number 1 Pittsburgh and Number 2 Fordham (with Vince Lombardi playing) that ended scoreless. The Polo Grounds hosted the Army-Navy Game in 1913, 1915, 1916, 1917, 1918, 1919, 1920, 1921, 1923, 1925 and 1927.
In 1923, Luis Firpo knocked heavyweight champion Jack Dempsey out of the ring there, before Dempsey got back in and knocked Firpo out. In 1960, after Ingemar Johansson knocked Floyd Patterson out to win the title the year before at Yankee Stadium, Floyd got his revenge, knocking Ingo out to become the 1st man ever to regain the heavyweight title.
Of course, with very few living people who remember seeing John McGraw manage the Giants there, and possibly no one who saw Christy Mathewson pitch there, the Polo Grounds site is now best known for the 1951 Bobby Thomson home run where "The Giants win the Pennant! The Giants win the Pennant!" and the 1954 World Series catch by Willie Mays.
Now home to a housing project called Polo Grounds Towers, a plaque commemorating the ballpark is at the entrance to one of the buildings, roughly where home plate was. (If you see the plaque, you'll notice that it calls the Giants "1904 World Champions" – and Red Sox fans may feel free to laugh, as the Giants were too chicken to play the Boston Pilgrims in that year's World Series; while the Sox don't recognize themselves as 1904 World Champions, they should.) Part of the complex is a playground named Willie Mays Field, though it's not really a "field."
157th Street & 8th Avenue (Frederick Douglass Blvd.). Take the D train to 155th Street. Right across 155th Street is Rucker Park, home of a legendary local basketball tournament.
The original Polo Grounds, where polo actually had been played, was at 110th Street and 5th Avenue, at the northeast corner of Central Park, from 1876 to 1889, until the City ordered 111th Street built through it, forcing the Giants out. Number 2 or 3 train to 110th Street.
* Site of Ebbets Field. Home of the Brooklyn Dodgers from 1913 to 1957, and a football team called the Brooklyn Dodgers from 1930 to 1948. This was where the Dodgers, in their "Daffiness Boys" days of the 1930s, ended up with 3 men on base. "Yeah? Which base?" Where Jackie Robinson reintegrated the game in 1947. Where Leo Durocher argued with umpires, where Hilda Chester rang her cowbell, and where the Dodger Sym-Phony Band played their instruments, but not well.
And where Brooklynites – really, people from all over the Tri-State Area – of all races, religions and ethnicities learned about baseball and life itself, and got a million thrills, and a few heartbreaks, none worse than when the team was taken from them in the days before the launch of Sputnik. (The very night of the last game, September 24, 1957, was the night President Eisenhower sent the 101st Airborne to integrate Little Rock Central High School. Ten years after Jackie, some people still didn't learn. Over half a century after that, some still haven't learned.)
Now home to a housing project called Ebbets Field Apartments, it is safe to visit during daylight. Bedford Avenue & Sullivan Place, where the neighborhoods of Flatbush, Crown Heights and Bedford-Stuyvesant come together.
Take the B or Q train to Prospect Park. Walk up Flatbush Avenue, with Prospect Park on your left, turn right on Empire Boulevard, then walk 3 blocks to McKeever Place, and one more block to Sullivan Place. To your right will be the project. To your left will be a school named after Robinson. At the corner of Bedford & Sullivan will be the complex's cornerstone, revealing it as the site of Ebbets Field.
* MCU Park, formerly known as KeySpan Park. Home to the Brooklyn Cyclones, a Mets farm team in the Class A New York-Penn League, since 2001. (It used to be known as the Pennsylvania-Ontario-New York League, or the PONY League.) The NYPL league is "Short-Season A-ball," meaning that they don't start until mid-June -- so if you want to see the Cyclones, the Staten Island Yankees, or any other team in the league, you'll have to wait until summer.
The team takes its name from Coney Island's iconic rollercoaster. A statue honoring Dodger legends Jackie Robinson and Harold "Pee Wee" Reese is outside. The Parachute Jump, an icon of Coney Island that had stood at the 1939-40 World's Fair and was a model for similar rides at Six Flags' parks, is outside the right field corner; although restored so that it won't collapse, it's no longer a functioning ride.
With 7,500 seats, and not a lot of history, MCU Park is not Ebbets Field, but it's a lot more convenient, and it's a nice place to see a professional game.
The Cyclones are not the old Dodger "Boys of Summer," but they win more often than not – unlike their parent club! They've won 5 Division Titles, and, since the 2001 NYPL finals were underway when the World Trade Center was attacked, the series was called off, and the Cyclones were declared Co-Champions, so they have won a Pennant.
In 2017, it also became the home of the reborn New York Cosmos, who had previously played their minor-league soccer at Long Island's Hofstra University.
1904 Surf Avenue, at 19th Street. Take the D, F, N or Q train to Coney Island-Stillwell Avenue. The Cyclone, still in operation, is at 8th & Surf, and the original Nathan's Famous hot dog stand is at Stillwell & Surf.
Information on early Brooklyn ballfields is available in my Trip Guides for the Nets and Islanders.
* Richmond County Bank Ballpark. Home to the Staten Island Yankees since 2001. Like the Cyclones, who are their arch-rivals, the "Baby Bombers" have had a bit of success since their arrival, winning 6 NYPL Pennants, most recently in 2011.
The park has a magnificent view of Lower Manhattan, across the harbor (though it had a better view for its first 2 months, before 9/11), and it's been remarked that it looks like the Statue of Liberty is playing a distant center field.
75 Richmond Terrace at Hamilton Avenue. Roughly on the site of the St. George Cricket Grounds, where the Giants had to play temporarily in 1889, but clinched a Pennant.
Take the R train to Whitehall Street -- Hurricane Sandy damaged the South Ferry station on the Number 1 line in 2012 and is now expected to reopen sometime in 2017 -- then cross the street to the Whitehall Terminal. The Staten Island Ferry is free, it takes 22 minutes in each direction, and you get a pretty good view of Lady Liberty. Then it's a 5-minute walk from the St. George Terminal.
(You're probably better off skipping a visit to Liberty Island, considering the lines and the security measures. As an icon, the Statue is priceless; as a tourist attraction, it's overrated.)
* Negro Leagues. Aside from the old Yankee Stadium, the Polo Grounds and Ebbets Field, all of which hosted Negro League games, there are 7 notable Negro League sites in the New York Tri-State Area. Two of them are in New Jersey, one in Newark and one in Paterson, and I'll get to those when I get to the New Jersey section.
From 1911 to 1919, the Lincoln Giants -- the name "Lincoln" a clue that they were an all-black team -- played at Olympic Field, at 136th Street and 5th Avenue in Harlem. 2 or 3 train to 135th Street.
From 1920 to 1929, after which the Great Depression caused them to fold, they played at the Catholic Protectory Oval in the Parkchester section of The Bronx. The Parkchester Apartments, a massive apartment complex, took the place of the Protectory, a former orphange. 6 train to Parkchester.
Triborough Stadium, on Randall's Island, with the Triborough Bridge going past it, opened in 1936, and hosted Negro League games from 1936 to 1940, including all home games of the New York Black Yankees in 1938.
It also hosted the Yankees of the 1936-37 version of the American Football League, the Yankees of the 1940-41 version of the AFL, and Olympic trials from 1936 to 1964. At the 1st one, Jesse Owens set a world record.
Later known as John J. Downing Memorial Stadium, the 22,000-seat horseshoe hosted the New York Stars of the World Football League in 1974, and was home to the original New York Cosmos in 1974 and '75, infamously having its horrible field painted green so it would look good on TV for Pelé's American debut. The U.S. national team lost to Scotland there in 1949 and to England in 1964.
Downing Stadium was demolished in 2002, in the hopes that a 48,000-seat soccer-specific stadium could be built there for the 2012 Olympics and Major League Soccer. That was scrapped, and the 5,000-seat Icahn Stadium opened there in 2005, hosting mainly track and field events. 20 Randall's Island. 4 or 5 Train to 125th Street, then Bus M35.
Dyckman Oval was a complex that had an athletic field and a running track in the Inwood section of Upper Manhattan. Various Negro League teams played games there, particularly the New York Cubans. In retrospect, this makes sense, since Manhattan from 155th Street on up is now mostly Hispanic, although mainly Puerto Rican and Dominican rather than Cuban.
It didn't last long, from 1923 until 1938. The Dyckman Houses went up on the site. Dyckman Street (effectively, West 200th) and 10th Avenue. 1 Train to Dyckman Street.
Dexter Park was home to black baseball's Brooklyn Royal Giants and a big semi-pro team called the Brooklyn Bushwicks, although it was actually in the Woodhaven section of Queens. Baseball was first played there in 1891, and an 8,000-seat replacement stadium was built there in 1923, eventually expanded to 15,400. In 1930, it became the 1st ballpark in the City to have lights and night games -- 8 years before Ebbets Field, 10 years before the Polo Grounds, and 16 years before Yankee Stadium.
It also hosted football, soccer, boxing and auto racing. But the decline of the Negro Leagues and semi-pro ball, both partly forced by the growth of baseball on TV, doomed Dexter Park, which closed in 1955. A C-Town supermarket and a liquor store are now on the site. 74-39 Jamaica Avenue at Dexter Court. Franklin K. Lane High School is adjacent, and a long fly ball to the west is Cypress Hills Cemetery, which I'll get to shortly. J or Z Train to 75th Street-Elders Lane.
* Madison Square Park. This is where the game of baseball was invented. Seriously. No, it wasn't in Cooperstown, New York; and General Abner Doubleday, Civil War hero though he was, had nothing to do with it. The Knickerbocker Base Ball Club used it as their home ground, and it was here that they tested the rules they wrote.
Surveyor (which job led him to conclude that 90 feet between the bases was best) and fireman Alexander Joy Cartwright has generally gotten credit, but Club members Daniel "Doc" Adams and William R. Wheaton were also heavily involved in writing the rules, and in getting them approved at 1857 and '58 conventions that standardized the various regional versions of what was then spelled as 2 words as "base ball," that became the difference between baseball and all baseball-like games that came before it.
The Square and Park were named for James Madison, Father of the Constitution and the nation's 4th President. At the intersection of 23rd Street, 5th Avenue and Broadway. At the southern end is the Flatiron Building, which was the tallest in New York from its 1903 opening until 1909 and remains a City icon.
At the northeast corner, at 26th Street and Madison Avenue, is the New York Life Building, built on the site of the first two buildings to have the name Madison Square Garden, 1879-1890 and 1891-1925. And now you know how the building got the name when its current version isn't (and last previous version wasn't, either) at Madison Square.
In addition to boxing, the earlier Gardens hosted all kinds of shows, from the Westminster Kennel Club show to Buffalo Bill Cody's Wild West Show to the 1924 Democratic Convention, taking 103 ballots -- a 2/3rds majority was needed to nominate under the rules of the time -- to nominate John W. Davis as a sacrificial lamb to Calvin Coolidge. 51 Madison Avenue at 26th Street. Take the N or R train to 23rd Street.
* Worldwide Plaza. This skyscraper, built in 1989, marks the site of the 3rd Madison Square Garden, still known as "the Old Garden" to old-timers.
From 1925 to 1942, it was home to the NHL's New York Americans; from 1926 to 1968, the NHL's New York Rangers (sort-of named for the building's fundraiser and owner, boxing promoter George "Tex" Rickard – "Tex's Rangers," get it?); and from 1946 to 1968, the NBA's New York Knickerbockers (named for Washington Irving's character Diedrich Knickerbocker, in whose voice he wrote his story collection A History of New York), or "Knicks."
The old Garden hosted what we would now call the NCAA Final Four in 1943 (Wyoming defeating Georgetown in the Final), 1944 (Utah over Dartmouth), 1945 (Oklahoma A&M, which became Oklahoma State in 1958, over New York University, despite The Garden being NYU's virtual home court), 1946 (Oklahoma State over North Carolina), 1947 (Holy Cross over Oklahoma), 1948 (Kentucky over Baylor), and 1950 (City College of New York, on its home court, completing the only NCAA/NIT double win by defeating Bradley).
It also hosted the National Invitation Tournament (NIT) and a few of the early NCAA basketball tournaments, until the 1951 point-shaving scandal knocked it, the NIT, and the schools that used the Garden as a 2nd home court (NYU, CCNY, St. John's and Long Island University) off the national radar.
Rickard made it the Mecca of Boxing, and Ned Irish, who promoted the legendary collegiate and pro doubleheaders and was one of the Knicks' owners, made it the Mecca of Basketball, although Red Sox fans, who are probably also Celtic fans, may disagree with that latter distinction. Neither Elvis Presley nor the Beatles ever played the old Garden.
50th Street & 8th Avenue. Take the C train to 50th Street, and on the downtown side of the station, you'll see a marble mural depicting the old Garden.
* Madison Square Garden. This "New Garden," which opened on February 11, 1968 and has been home to the Knicks, the Rangers, the NIT and (secondarily) Jamaica, Queens-based St. John's University's basketball team ever since, became the longest-lasting building with the name in May 2010, and celebrated its 50th Anniversary last month.
It was also home to the WNBA's New York Liberty from 1997 until 2010, and has been again since 2013, after a renovation, most of which took place in the NBA and NHL's off-seasons, led the Libs to take up residence at the Prudential Center in Newark. This Garden has never hosted the Final Four.
Elvis played a few shows at the Garden from June 7 to 10, 1972, and the Beatles did so on their individual solo tours, most notably George Harrison for his August 1, 1971 Concert for Bangladesh (which had fellow ex-Beatle Ringo Starr, plus Bob Dylan and Eric Clapton) and John Lennon for his August 30, 1972 One-to-One Concert (with his wife Yoko Ono, Stevie Wonder and Roberta Flack). What turned out to be John's last concert appearance was as Elton John's guest on Thanksgiving night, November 28, 1974.
Other notable shows include the July 27-29, 1973 Led Zeppelin shows filmed for The Song Remains the Same; the Bob Dylan tribute on October 16, 1992; the Concert for New York City on October 20, 2001 in the wake of the 9/11 attacks; the Big Apple to Big Easy show after Hurricane Katrina on September 20, 2005; and the "12-12-12" concert for Hurricane Sandy relief on December 12, 2012.
Elton John and Billy Joel have played the place more than any other performers, and thus have "retired numbers" in the Garden rafters, along with Knick and Ranger legends such as Walt Frazier and Mark Messier. Indeed, there have been years when Elton and the Grateful Dead sold the Garden out more than the Knicks did.
The Democratic Convention was held here in 1976 and 1980, both times nominating Jimmy Carter; and in 1992, nominating Bill Clinton. The Republican Convention was held here in 2004, renominating George W. Bush.
Tours of The Garden are available, at $18 and $27, depending on the level of access. At 32nd Street & 7th Avenue, on top of Penn Station (much as the Boston Garden and its successor were built on top of North Station). Because it's between 7th and 8th Avenues, just about every Subway line on the West Side comes within a block of the place.
* Barclays Center. The first new indoor sports arena in New York City since the "New Garden" in 1968, it opened in September 2012, and is the home of the NBA's recently-moved-and-renamed Brooklyn Nets. In October 2015, it became the home of the NHL's New York Islanders.
It actually has a smaller seating capacity than The Garden: Basketball, 17,732 to 19,763; hockey, 14,500 to 18,200. In fact, unless some other team has an unexpected move soon, the Barclays will have the smallest capacity in the NHL, less than the Nassau Coliseum's 16,297. But it will be incredibly more convenient and comfortable than the "Mausoleum," especially for Ranger and Devil fans wanting to see their team play away to the Isles.
Barclays is a banking and financial services company based in London, and has long been a sponsor of English's soccer's top division, the Premier League. (BPL stands for "Barclays Premier League," not "British Premier League.")
It seems kind of odd that an arena in Brooklyn would have this sponsor, but then, the new Boston Garden is named for TD Bank -- the TD stands for Toronto Dominion. Besides, what Brooklyn-based company could they have gone to? Nathan's? Dr. Brown's? (The soda, not the Back to the Future
scientist.) With all the Brooklyn pride the arena has tried to generate (and has begun to succeed in doing), it would have been rather awkward to call it the Manhattan Special Arena, even though beverage company Manhattan Special is headquartered in Brooklyn.
620 Atlantic Avenue, at Flatbush Avenue, across Atlantic from the Brooklyn Terminal of the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR), on the site that Walter O'Malley originally wanted for the site of the replacement for Ebbets Field, but they wouldn't let him build there. D or 4 Train to Atlantic Avenue.
* College football. Although NYU (New York University) and CCNY (City College of New York) once had strong football teams, only 2 Division I college football programs are left in New York City: Columbia in Manhattan, and Fordham in The Bronx. Both are in the FCS, the Football Championship Subdivision -- what used to be known as "Division I-AA," the 2nd tier of American college football.
While Columbia won win the Rose Bowl on New Year's Day 1934 (back when Ivy League teams were allowed to play postseason games), and their 1947 win over mighty Army is known as "The Miracle of Morningside Heights," the program is now best known for their 44-game losing streak from 1983 to 1988, a Division I record since broken.
While the broken window scene from The Pride of the Yankees, the film with Gary Cooper playing Lou Gehrig, did actually happen, at South Field, on College Walk (116th Street) between Broadway and Amsterdam (10th) Avenue, across from the stately Low Library, Columbia moved even further uptown shortly after Gehrig reached the Yankees.
They played at Baker Field from 1923 to 1983, and the 1st televised baseball game ever was broadcast from there in 1939, between Columbia and Princeton. (The Dodgers would host the 1st televised major league game later in the year.)
In 1984, Baker Field was replaced on the same site with Lawrence A. Wien Stadium, named for a real estate tycoon who left the university a lot of money. The field within the stadium has recently been named for another Columbia graduate and major donor, New England Patriots owner Robert Kraft. So, yes, a notable New York City sports facility is named after a New England sports legend.
Later in 1939, Fordham played in the 1st televised football game, beating Waynesburg 34-7. That game was played at Triborough (Downing) Stadium. Fordham's best days were already winding down by '39 (they had memorable battles with the University of Pittsburgh the preceding 2 years, '37 at the Polo Grounds and '38 at Pitt Stadium), and they could no longer command big crowds at the Polo Grounds or Yankee Stadium.
Baker Field/Wien Stadium/Kraft Field is at 218th Street & Broadway, at the northern tip of Manhattan Island. (1 train to 215th Street.)
Fordham plays at Jack Coffey Field, opened in 1930 and renovated in 2004. All Fordham University buildings have an official address of 441 East Fordham Road, at Kazimiroff Blvd. Metro-North to Fordham, or D train to Fordham Road, and then walk down Fordham Road.
While both Columbia and Fordham are noted for their toniness and their good security forces, neither of these locations is to be visited at night.
* Site of St. Nicholas Arena. From 1896 to 1962, this arena was used for ice skating, hockey and boxing. It was also used as a TV studio for ABC from 1953 onward.
After its demolition, ABC built a new studio on the site, and the local Eyewitness News, Live
(formerly with Regis Philbin and Kathie Lee Gifford, now with Kelly Ripa and Ryan Seacrest), Who Wants to Be a Millionaire? (formerly hosted by Philbin, now by Chris Harrison) and The View are taped there.
69 W. 66th Street at Columbus Avenue, across from the Lincoln Center for the Performing Arts. 1 Train to 66th Street-Lincoln Square.
NBC's studios are at the GE Building on Avenue of the Americas, which everybody still calls the RCA Building on 6th Avenue. 30 Rockefeller Plaza, or 30 Rock for short, between 49th and 50th Streets. A walkway leads from it to 5th Avenue, across from St. Patrick's Cathedral. B or D train to 47th-50th Streets-Rockefeller Center.
CBS' studios are at the CBS Building, fronted by black marble and thus known as Black Rock. 51 W. 52nd Street at 6th Avenue. Reached by the same station as NBC.
* New Jersey. Aside from the intrasquad games played by the Knickerbocker Club at Madison Square in 1845, the 1st baseball game under their rules was played against an established club, the New York Base Ball Club (known to history as "The New York Nine"), at the Elysian Fields in Hoboken, Hudson County. The New York Club won 23-1 in 4 innings, as 21 runs then constituted a win as long as each side played an equal number of innings.
Baseball would continue to be played there until 1873. Most of the site was occupied by a Maxwell House coffee factory that has since been turned into condominiums, although the famous music club Maxwell's has its front door roughly where 3rd base was. 1039 Washington Street. PATH to Hoboken Terminal.
You can take New Jersey Transit's 320 bus from Port Authority to the Meadowlands Sports Complex, just off the New Jersey Turnpike's Exit 16W, at NJ-Routes 3 & 120. You can also take a train there from Penn Station, but only on Giants or Jets game days.
The Giants played at Giants Stadium from 1976 to 2009, the Jets from 1984 to 2009, the North American Soccer League's New York Cosmos from 1977 to 1984, and Major League Soccer's local team – known as the New York-New Jersey MetroStars until 2005 when they became the New York Red Bulls – from 1996 to 2009.
Rutgers University played some home games there from 1976 to 1995, including the entire 1993 season, while they built their new on-campus stadium on the site of the old one. The Army-Navy Game was held there in 1989, 1993, 1997 and 2002. Games of the 1994 World Cup and the 1999 Women's World Cup were held there.
Both NFL teams moved into MetLife Stadium, which hosted Super Bowl XLVIII in 2014, Seattle over Denver. Like Giants Stadium, MetLife is also a major venue for big-act concerts and soccer. The U.S. team played 9 games at Giants Stadium, winning 4, losing 2 and drawing 3. They've now played 2 at MetLife, a loss to Brazil in 2010 and a draw vs. Argentina in 2011. (I was there, watching North Brunswick, New Jersey native Tim Howard stop Lionel Messi on all 5 shots he took.)
The Nets played at the Meadowlands arena, which has had a bunch of names and is currently known as the Izod Center, from 1981 to 2010, and the Devils played there from 1982 to 2007. The only Final Four played in the Tri-State Area since 1950 was held here, in 1996, with Kentucky beating Syracuse in the Final. The Arena was closed in 2015, and is likely to be demolished within the next 5 years.
The Devils and the Seton Hall University basketball team (in games too big for their 3,200-seat on-campus gym in South Orange) play at the Prudential Center, which opened in 2007 at Broad & Lafayette Streets in downtown Newark. The WNBA's Liberty also played there in 2011 and 2012, during "The Garden Transformed," Madison Square Garden's renovation during the off-seasons for the Knicks and Rangers, but during the regular season for the Libs.
Take NJT's Northeast Corridor Line train from New York's Penn Station to Newark's station of the same name, or the PATH (Port Authority Trans-Hudson) train from 33rd Street & 6th Avenue (Herald Square, 1 block from New York Penn Station) to Newark Penn. In spite of a bad reputation for the city in general, downtown Newark is safe.
Red Bull Arena, home to the Tri-State Area's original MLS team since 2010, is in Harrison, a 5-minute walk from the Harrison station on the PATH line. This will also be safe, even if you root for D.C. United. (A new Harrison station is in the first stages of construction, because the old station is a major bottleneck.) It's hosted the Red Bulls, and some international matches, including 4 matches of the U.S. men's team (most recently the catastrophic September 1, 2017 loss to Costa Rica) and 5 matches of the U.S. women's team.
Less safe is the site of Ruppert Stadium, home of the International League's Newark Bears (farm team of the Yankees) starting in 1926 and the Negro Leagues' Newark Eagles starting in 1936. At 19,000 seats, it was one of the biggest ballparks in the minor leagues, and was home to, among others, future Hall-of-Famers Yogi Berra, Monte Irvin and Ray Dandridge. But the integration of the majors killed the Negro Leagues, and television nearly killed the minor leagues. Both teams were gone after the 1949 season, and Ruppert Stadium was torn down in 1967.
If you simply don't have time to visit all these sites, and have to cut some, this should be the first one you cut. 258 Wilson Avenue at Avenue K. NJT 25 Bus.
The new team called the Newark Bears was shut down due to financial difficulties. They played in the Atlantic League from 1998 to 2009, and in the Can-Am League from 2010 to 2013. Whether they will ever begin play again is anybody's guess. They played at Bears & Eagles Riverfront Stadium (honoring both of Ruppert's tenants), at 450 Broad Street at Division Street, across from NJT's Broad Street Station. You're better off taking NJT to Newark's Penn Station and then taking Newark Light Rail to Riverfront Stadium stop.
These Bears won Pennants in the Atlantic League in 2002 and 2007, and previously had a rivalry with the Somerset Patriots, who play at TD Bank Ballpark in Bridgewater, Somerset County, between Somerville and Bound Brook. The Pats have won 5 Atlantic League Pennants, with former Yankee reliever Sparky Lyle managing them until 2012. East Main Street & Cole Drive. Bridgewater station on NJT's Raritan Valley Line, although you'll need to change trains at Newark Penn Station.
Upon switching to the Can-Am League, the Bears' new rivals were the New Jersey Jackals, who play at Yogi Berra Stadium on the campus of Montclair State University in Little Falls. (The campus straddles the line between that town and Montclair.) The Jackals have won 4 Pennants, most recently in 2004.
Attached to the ballpark is the Yogi Berra Museum & Learning Center, honoring Yogi, the Yankees, and local baseball in general. The original Plaques that DiMaggio and Mantle got, before being replaced by Monuments, are there, as are a statue of Yogi, his 3 Most Valuable Player trophies, and some seats from the old Yankee Stadium. MSU stop on NJT's Montclair-Boonton Line, or NJT Number 28 bus.
Another site that hosted the "high minors" was Roosevelt Stadium in Jersey City. Built by Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal agency, the Works Project Administration, and named for him by the city, it was at Danford Avenue and State Route 1 -- now State Route 440 because U.S. Route 1 cuts through the city -- and seated 24,000, making it home of the International League's Jersey City Giants from 1937 to 1950 (the Giants farm team was yet another minor-league club killed by TV), and a few other teams until its demolition in 1985.
The stadium also hosted 15 Brooklyn Dodger "home games" in 1956 and '57, as Walter O'Malley saw a stadium even smaller than Ebbets Field but with a hell of a lot more parking. It also hosted high school football games, including doubleheaders on Thanksgiving Day. This is another site to take in only if you have lots of time and can visit it in daylight.
Hinchliffe Stadium in Paterson is a 10,000-seat horseshoe built in 1932 that looks like a large high school football stadium, which it is. But it hosted the Negro Leagues' New York Cubans in 1935 and '36. It also hosted shows by Abbott & Costello, since Lou Costello was from Paterson. NJT Bus 190 from Port Authority to Paterson's Broadway Terminal, then Bus 712.
Three New Jersey cities have statues honoring Baseball Hall-of-Famers: Jersey City, where Jackie Robinson played his first game in "organized ball" (Montreal Royals at Jersey City Giants), has a statue of him in Journal Square; Larry Doby, born in South Carolina but raised in Paterson, has one at a field named for him; and the now heavily-Hispanic Newark has one of Roberto Clemente in Branch Brook Park.
The Yankees' Double-A farm team is the Trenton Thunder, who play at Arm & Hammer Park (formerly Mercer County Waterfront Park), at Cass & Lamberton Streets in Trenton. Players working back into shape after injuries will often be sent here for rehab games.
Although the Thunder have been enormously successful in attendance -- the high prices and lack of availability of Yankees and Phillies tickets has caused this -- they were not been all that successful as a Red Sox farm team. They blew sure Pennants in the 1996 and '99 Eastern League Playoffs, finally winning Pennants as a Yankee farm team in 2007, '08 and '13.
NJT Northeast Corridor Line to Trenton Transit Center, then RiverLine to Cass Street, and 8 blocks to the ballpark. Yeah, it's a long walk, and you'll pass the New Jersey State Prison; but the buses don't go there, and you'll pass a nice ballpark mural along the way.
The Phillies have a Class A team near the Jersey Shore, the Lakewood BlueClaws. They've won South Atlantic League (a.k.a. "Sally League") Pennants in 2006, '09 and '10. Cedar Bridge & New Hampshire Avenues. NJT to Newark, then 67 Bus to New Hampshire Avenue. Though you're more likely to want to go there if you're a Phillies fan, so: From Philly's Greyhound station, take NJT's 317 Bus to New Hampshire Avenue.
The Louis Brown Athletic Center, formerly the Rutgers Athletic Center and still nicknamed the RAC, home to the Nets from 1977 to 1981, is in Piscataway, as is Rutgers Stadium. Built in 1938 for 23,000 fans, totally reconstructed in 1994 for 41,500, and expanded in 2009 for 52,454, the location has hosted 4 U.S. soccer team matches, most recently a 1995 draw against Colombia. A 3-minute walk from the Stadium is the 5,000-seat Yurcak Field, RU's soccer and lacrosse facility, which is home to Sky Blue FC, the New York franchise in the National Women's Soccer League.
To get to Rutgers, take New Jersey Transit's Northeast Corridor Line to New Brunswick, and switch to a Rutgers "Campus Bus," the A to the Busch Campus to the stadium, the L to the Livingston Campus to the RAC, or the B between them.
Princeton, a much nicer college town, features Powers Field at Princeton University Stadium and Jadwin Gym. Powers Field was built on the site of Palmer Stadium (1914-1996), and Jadwin, long the home of the State high school wrestling championships (since moved to Atlantic City), is at the open, southern end of the horseshoe. In 1905, Palmer's predecessor, Osborne Field, hosted the Army-Navy Game. It's also worth noting that the University of Michigan's "winged" helmet design was brought there by coach Fritz Crisler, who originated it at his previous head coaching post, Princeton. A few years back, Princeton started wearing the design again, with black wings on an orange helmet.
The town can be reached via Coach USA bus from Port Authority. It can also be reached via NJ Transit's Northeast Corridor to Princeton Junction, and then transfer to a shuttle (known locally as "The Dinky") to Princeton proper.
The Nets played the 1st season of the ABA, 1967-68, as the New Jersey Americans -- making them the 1st team to represent New Jersey in anything resembling a major league since the 1915 Newark Peppers of the Federal League. They played at an armory in Teaneck, Bergen County, built in 1936. They didn't do well attendance-wise, and moved to Long Island after 1 season.
The building still stands, and in 1997 was renovated. It is now known as the Soccer Coliseum, and indoor soccer is played there. 1799 Teaneck Road at Liberty Road. New Jersey Transit 167 or 177 bus from Port Authority.
Take the LIRR's Hempstead Branch all the way to the end. Across the street is a bus station. Take the N70, N71 or N72 bus (N for Nassau), and it's a 10-minute ride down the Jericho Turnpike to Uniondale.
Adjacent is Hofstra University, including its 11,929-seat James M. Shuart Stadium, and the former Jets offices and training complex, Weeb Ewbank Hall. The Hofstra baseball field has a statue of Casey Stengel.
Hofstra played football at Shuart Stadium from its opening in 1963 until the program's cancellation in 2009. It still hosts decent soccer and lacrosse programs, was the home field of the NASL's New York Cosmos from 1972 to 1974, and hosted the reborn Cosmos from 2011 to 2016.
The Long Island Ducks, an Atlantic League baseball team named for a former minor-league hockey team, are the only professional sports team in The Island's Suffolk County. They play at Bethpage Ballpark, but it's not in the town of Bethpage. Rather, it's at Court House Drive & Carleton Avenue, on the campus of the New York Institute of Technology in Central Islip. (Try not to pronounce that as two words: "I slip.") LIRR Ronkonkoma Line to Central Islip station, then it's a 2-mile walk down Lowell & Eastview Avenues. (Taxis are available at the station.)
The 4,000-seat Long Island Arena, also known as the Commack Arena, opened in 1956, and from 1959 until 1973 -- forced into irrelevancy and dissolution by the arrival of the Islanders -- it was home to the original team called the Long Island Ducks, of the Eastern Hockey League.
The ABA team arrived, and, to rhyme with the Mets and the Jets, changed their name to the New York Nets -- admittedly, a dumb name with a dumb reason. They were terrible in that 1968-69 season, and found the floor unacceptable, full of pits and gouges, and with condensation from the ice beneath coming up, making it slick. After 1 season, the Nets moved again, for reasons that had little to do with poor attendance or performance.
Built across the street from the original Island Garden, which hosted rock concerts from 1957 to 1968, the Nets managed to stay at the new Island Garden for 3 seasons, from 1969 to 1972. Seating just 8,500 people, the opening of the Nassau Coliseum made it obsolete. (Yes, kids, the "Mausoleum" made another arena obsolete.)
It was demolished in 1973, and, as with the Long Island/Commack Arena, a shopping center is on the site today. But so is a part of the original arena, and youth basketball is still played there. 45 Cherry Valley Avenue at Terminal Road, West Hempstead. LIRR Hempstead Branch to Queens Village, then transfer to MTA N6 bus.
The Belmont Park was built just over the City Line, in Elmont, Nassau County, in 1905. It was torn down and replaced by a new grandstand in 1968. Except for 1963 to 1967 -- when it was held at nearby Aqueduct, in Queens -- the Belmont Stakes, the last leg of the Triple Crown, has been held there since 1905.
A new 18,000-seat arena for the Islanders has been approved adjacent to the racetrack, currently scheduled to open for the 2020-21 season. 2150 Hempstead Turnpike. The LIRR has a station there.
* Lower Hudson Valley. The Hudson Valley Renegades have won New York-Penn League Pennants in 1999, 2012 and 2017. They play at Dutchess Stadium in Wappingers Falls in Dutchess County. Although the ballpark is just a mile or so from the Hudson River, and the river-hugging Hudson Line of the Metro-North Commuter Railroad, Wappingers Falls does not have a Metro-North Station. You'd have to take the Hudson Line (formerly the centerpiece of the New York Central Railroad) to Beacon, and then either walk or take a cab over the remaining 2 miles up N.Y. State Route 9D.
That's on the east bank of the Hudson. On the west bank is the Tri-State Area's newest pro baseball team, the Rockland Boulders. They play at Provident Bank Park at 300 Pomona Road in Pomona, Rockland County. Don't bother trying to reach this one by public transportation, as it's over 4 miles from the nearest train line and there's no bus that goes there.
* Connecticut. The Bridgeport Bluefish played from 1999 to 2017 at The Ballpark at Harbor Yard, in Bridgeport, the most populous city in the State of Connecticut, and the seat of Fairfield County. The Fish won just 1 Atlantic League Pennant, in 1999, but were Division Champions as recently as 2010. But they had to move after the City of Bridgeport announced new plans for the stadium.
Adjacent is Webster Bank Arena, formerly The Arena at Harbor Yard, which hosts the Bridgeport Sound Tigers, a farm team of the Islanders. This is made a lot easier by the fact that there's a ferry between Bridgeport and the Long Island town of Port Jefferson, across Long Island Sound.
A statue of Bridgeport native Jim "Orator" O'Rourke, a Hall-of-Famer, is outside. Metro-North New Haven Line to Bridgeport, then 5 blocks down Water Street, under I-95/Connecticut Turnpike.
Most of the New York side of Connecticut remains Ranger fans, and even the Boston side has a lot of Ranger fans because their farm team, the Hartford Wolf Pack, is a Ranger farm team, standing in for the now-gone Hartford Whalers at the XL Center, formerly the Hartford Civic Center.
So while there are a few Bruin fans on the Boston side of the Nutmeg State, Islander fans in and around Bridgeport, and a few people trying to bring the NHL back to Hartford in a renovated Civic Center or a new arena, the Rangers lead the State's hockey fandom.
Yale Field in West Haven, just outside the New Haven City Line, was built in 1928, and is one of the oldest surviving ballparks. It hosted the New Haven Ravens of the Eastern League from 1994 to 2003, and the New Haven County Cutters of the Can-Am League from 2004 to 2007. It is still used by Yale University, but no pro team plays there now.
I saw the Ravens beat the Trenton Thunder there, 3-2 in 10 innings, on July 18, 1999, a brutally hot day. There's a little (maybe 10 seats) sports bar in the left field corner, with TVs. Late in the game I saw, it was announced that David Cone had a perfect game after 8 innings. There were maybe 3,000 people in the park, and about 2,900 of them rushes to that little bar to see if Coney could finish it off, even though there was a pretty good game going on below, for which they had already paid. (Cone did finish the perfect game.)
Yale University's athletic complex straddles Derby Avenue, with the Field on the south side. On the north side is the Yale Bowl, where the Bulldogs have played football since 1914. A recent renovation has cut the seating capacity from 71,000 to 61,446, but it's in much shape as it celebrates its centennial.
Due to Mayor John Lindsay's anger at the Giants for leaving the City for the Meadowlands, into whose stadium they wouldn't be able to move until 1976, he denied them use of Shea once Yankee Stadium closed for renovation. So they went to the Yale Bowl, even though it's 75 miles northeast of Midtown Manhattan, and played the rest of their 1973 home games and all their 1974 home games there, before new Mayor Abe Beame let them play at Shea in 1975.
The 1st Giants-Jets game ever was played at the Yale Bowl, in the 1969 preseason, and the Jets won that, solidifying themselves as champions of not just the world, as they'd shown in Super Bowl III 7 months earlier, but of New York City. The Yale Bowl has also hosted 2 U.S. soccer matches, a loss to Brazil in 1993 and a draw with Greece in 1994.
Derby & Yale Avenues. Metro-North New Haven Line to New Haven Union Station, walk to New Haven Green, and then Connecticut Transit B bus.
Oddly enough, from 1972 to 1979, when the Yankees had a Double-A farm team in "New Haven," they were the West Haven Yankees, but they did not play at Yale Field, which was then rather dilapidated. (I guess all those Yalies weren't donating money to fix the athletic facilities.) They played instead at Quigley Stadium, at 362 Front Avenue, which has a much smaller capacity and is also pretty old, dating to 1947. It now hosts only high school football.
In retirement, Jackie Robinson and his family left Brooklyn and settled in Stamford. Jackie Robinson Park of Fame, including a statue of him, is at 860 Canal Street at Henry Street. A 15-minute walk from the Stamford Station on Metro-North.
Legends Laid to Rest. The cemeteries at which Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig are buried are right next-door to each other, even though they're officially in separate towns.
Gate of Heaven Cemetery in Hawthorne, Westchester County, is the final resting place of Ruth, Billy Martin, umpire John McSherry, football Giants owners Tim and Wellington Mara, Los Angeles Rams founder-owner Dan Reeves (no relation to the former Giants, Denver and Atlanta coach), sportswriters Heywood Broun and Bob Considine, journalist & What's My Line panelist Dorothy Kilgallen, actor and Yankee Fan James Cagney, actor Sal Mineo, legendary comedian Fred Allen, 1920s New York Mayor Jimmy Walker, union leader Mike Quill, and mobster Dutch Schultz. 10 W. Stevens Avenue, Hawthorne. Metro-North to Mount Pleasant.
Kensico Cemetery in Valhalla, of which Gate of Heaven is an offshoot, is the final resting place of Gehrig, Yankee owner Jacob Ruppert, infamous Red Sox owner Harry Frazee, actress Anne Bancroft (presumably, her husband, Mel Brooks, will join her there), comedian Danny Kaye, Big Band leader Tommy Dorsey (but not his brother Jimmy), composer Sergei Rachmaninoff, RCA (and therefore NBC) founder David Sarnoff, poet Gil Scott-Heron, Broadway producer Florenz Ziegfeld, author Paddy Chayefsky, 1930s New York Governor Herbert Lehman, and opera singers Robert Merrill (who frequently sang the National Anthem at Yankee games) and Beverly Sills. 273 Lakeview Avenue. Metro-North to Valhalla.
Yogi Berra is buried at a different Gate of Heaven Cemetery. 225 Ridgedale Avenue, East Hanover, Morris County, New Jersey. Not easily reachable by public transportation. Elston Howard is buried at George Washington Memorial Park. 234 Paramus Road, Paramus, Bergen County. NJ Transit Bus 163 from Port Authority. Mel Allen is buried at Temple Beth El Cemetery. Not easily reachable by public transportation.
Green-Wood Cemetery in Brooklyn is where you can find several early baseball legends, including "The Father of Baseball," Henry Chadwick, America's 1st great sportswriter. (But not, as was long believed, the inventor of the box score.) His gravemarker is one of the more elaborate you'll ever see. So is that of James Creighton, the early player who appears to have been the first pitcher to purposely throw hard, thus inventing the fastball. He was the 1st real baseball superstar, but no sooner had he achieved that status than he died of causes still debated -- at age 21, in 1862. Charles Ebbets, Brooklyn Dodger owner and ballpark builder, is also buried there.
Non-baseball personalities buried there include composer Leonard Bernstein, longtime New York Governor and Senator DeWitt Clinton, sewing machine inventor Elias Howe, Constitution signer and 1st New Jersey Governor William Livingston, legendarily corrupt New York political boss William Tweed, painter and telegraph inventor Samuel Morse, abolitionist preacher Henry Ward Beecher, artist Jean-Michel Basquiat, both Nathaniel Currier and James Ives, Louis Comfort Tiffany, mobster Albert Anastasia, actor DeWolf Hoppper (whose onstage recitation, in those days before most people had record players, popularized "Casey at the Bat"), Wizard of Oz portrayer Frank Morgan, piano manufacturers Henry and William Steinway, and songwriter Fred Ebb, who wrote the lyrics to "Theme From New York, New York." (You know: "Start spreadin' the news... ")
Also the parents, uncle and 1st wife of President Theodore Roosevelt. And the namesakes of 2 of the major components of New Jersey's Rutgers University: Revolutionary War hero and philanthropist Henry Rutgers, and educator Mabel Smith Douglass. 500 25th Street, Brooklyn. N train to 36th Street.
Woodlawn Cemetery in The Bronx is not the final resting place of any Yankee Legends, unless you count 1947-64 co-owner Dan Topping. And the only Baseball Hall-of-Famer buried there is Bronx native and Giants star Frankie Frisch. But its the burial place of 1970 Knick Dean Meminger, swimmer Gertude Edele, boxing promoter and "old Garden" builder Tex Rickard, and sportswriters Grantland Rice and Damon Runyon.
Music legends buried there include Irving Berlin, George M. Cohan, Celia Cruz, Miles Davis, Duke Ellington, Lionel Hampton and W.C. Handy. It's also where you can find Mayor Fiorello LaGuardia, early 20th Century Republican political figure Charles Evans Hughes, New York's master builder (but also a big reason why the Dodgers moved) Robert Moses, diplomat Ralph Bunche, Civil War naval hero David Farragut, department store founders Rowland H. Macy and James Cash Penney, novelist Herman Melville, cartoonist Thomas Nast, newspaper publisher Joseph Pulitzer, journalism pioneer Nellie Bly, and Wild West figure Bat Masterson. 517 East 233rd Street. 4 Train to the end of the line, Woodlawn station.
Cypress Hills Cemetery straddles the Brooklyn-Queens "border." It is the final resting place of Jackie Robinson. An earlier Brooklyn baseball star buried there is Bob Ferguson, who, by the standards of his time, was such a good fielder he was known as "Death to Flying Things." It's also where you can find late 19th Century heavyweight champion Gentleman Jim Corbett, jazz pianist Eubie Blake, and actress Mae West. In case you want to "Come up sometime and see me," it's at 833 Jamaica Avenue. J to Cypress Hills.
Calvary Cemetery in Queens has 3 Hall-of-Famers: 1880s Giants pitcher Mickey Welch, 1890s Baltimore Oriole and Brooklyn Superba and 1900s New York Highlander Willie Keeler (he of the 44-game hitting streak and the advice to "Hit 'em where they ain't"), and Negro Leaguer Cristobal Torriente. 49-02 Laurel Hill Blvd. 7 Train to 52nd Street-Lincoln Avenue.
Non-Sports Sidelights. If you're looking for a good time to visit New York other than during baseball season, I would recommend the week before Christmas. Yes, it is likely to be cold, but the City never looks better than in the walk down 5th Avenue from 59th Street (Central Park, Plaza Hotel, and, until 2016, the now-closed legendary toy store FAO Schwarz), past the Trump Tower (57th), St. Patrick's Cathedral (51st), Rockefeller Center (49th), the main library (42nd) on down to 34th (the Empire State Building). Along the way, you'll pass other legendary stores, including Tiffany and Lord & Taylor, although B. Altman's is long gone.
Do not visit Times Square on New Year's Eve. I cannot emphasize this enough. The Square will be packed before dark. If you don't get there before dark, you won't get anywhere near it. And if you do get there before dark, you'll be stuck there for hours, until the crowd finally thins out a few minutes after midnight. I was once there at about 2:00 in the afternoon on a December 31, and it was already a zoo. Trust me on this one: Don't do it!
Also, don't visit on March 17 to see the St. Patrick's Day Parade, unless you like very raucous behavior by people who aren't the least bit Irish and are using the holiday as an excuse to get as drunk as they think the stereotypical Irishman is.
I would advise against seeing a Broadway show: Tickets are expensive, hard to get, and most of the shows aren't really worth it.
The Ed Sullivan Theater, previously known as CBS Studio 50, was the site for The Ed Sullivan Show from 1948 to 1971. Elvis appeared there on September 9 and October 28, 1956, and, with the CBS cameras showing him from the waist up only, on January 6, 1957. The Beatles played there on February 9, 1964 -- where a since-broken U.S. TV record of 73 million people watched -- and September 12, 1965. CBS now broadcasts The Late Show with David Letterman from there. 1697 Broadway at 54th Street; B, D or E train to 7th Avenue.
The Paramount Theatre on Times Square was home to some legendary concerts, including the Beatles to close their 1st North American tour on September 20, 1964. The parents of the Beatlemaniacs had nothing to say, because they screamed over Frank Sinatra there, culminating in "the Columbus Day Riot" on October 12, 1944. Built in 1926, it ceased operating as a movie theater in 1966, but it still stands, its bottom floors converted into retail space, including a Hard Rock Cafe. 1501 Broadway, at 43rd Street.
Also well worth a visit: The Empire State Building (34th Street & 5th Avenue, D Train to 34th Street), Grand Central Terminal (42nd Street & Park Avenue, Number 4 Train to 42nd Street or Number 7 Train to Grand Central), the American Museum of Natural History (81st Street & Central Park West, C Train to 81st Street), the Metropolitan Museum of Art (82nd Street & 5th Avenue, Number 4 Train to 86th Street & walk 10 minutes), the Intrepid Museum (the World War II-era aircraft carrier is at Pier 86, 46th Street & 12th Avenue, and includes several aircraft, including the prototype space shuttle Enterprise), and the South Street Seaport (Fulton & Front Streets, A Train to Broadway-Nassau).
The site of the World Trade Center (Church & Vesey Streets, E Train to World Trade Center) is across Manhattan Island from the Seaport, but at that point the island is so narrow that the walk takes just 15 minutes. The new World Trade Center's observation deck, the tallest building in the Western Hemisphere, is now open. Fulton to Church to Vesey.
Presidential Sites. There have been 2 Presidents born in New York City. And the 1st would have slapped the 2nd. Theodore Roosevelt Birthplace National Historic Site, a recreation of the townhouse where TR was born in 1858, demolished in 1916, and rebuilt after his death in 1919, is at 28 East 20th Street. N or R train to 23rd Street.
His home on Long Island, Sagamore Hill, recently reopened after a 2-year renovation. There's also a visitors' center and museum on the site that, for all intents and purposes, serves as TR's "Presidential Library" (since most people who visit Presidential Libraries see only the museum and, if there is one there, the house, and don't actually go into the library to view documents).
20 Sagamore Hill Road, Oyster Bay. LIRR to Oyster Bay, and then take a taxi. I've walked the 3 miles from the station to the house, and I don't recommend it: The roads are narrow and twisty, and Cove Neck Road and Sagamore Hill Road have nasty hills.
Donald Trump was born at
Franklin Delano Roosevelt, TR's cousin, and his wife Eleanor (TR's niece) had an apartment at 125 East 36th Street (6 to 33rd Street), and another at 49 East 65th Street off Park (F to Lexington Avenue/63rd Street). But their best-known home was FDR's birthplace in Hyde Park, in Dutchess County, where he put his Presidential Library.
4079 Albany Post Road, and if you're familiar with U.S. Route 9 in Jersey or as upper Broadway in Manhattan and The Bronx, or as the George Washington Bridge between them, it is very hard to believe it is (at least officially) the same road. It's 86 miles from Midtown Manhattan, and is actually closer to Albany. If you can't drive there, you'll have to take Metro-North from Grand Central to Poughkeepsie and then get a taxi for the last 4 miles. (It's not as hard a walk as from Oyster Bay to Sagamore Hill, but it is longer.)
As New York was the nation's 1st capital after ratification of the Constitution (but only very briefly before it moved back to Philadelphia and then to Washington), some of our early Presidents lived there, but none of their homes, or even the "Capitol," remain standing. Federal Hall, where George Washington was sworn in as the 1st President on April 30, 1789, was demolished in 1812 and rebuilt as a Customs House in 1842, and is now a National Park site. 26 Wall Street at Broad Street, on the opposite corner from the New York Stock Exchange. (4 or 5 to Wall Street.)
"The first White House," if you want to call it that, where Washington lived while New York was the capital, was at 3 Cherry Street, off Catherine Street, on what's now the Lower East Side, between the Brooklyn and Manhattan Bridges. There's a plaque on the building that's there now. F to East Broadway, then a 7-block walk down Rutgers and Cherry Streets.
John Adams lived in a house whose site is now occupied by the WNYC and WQXR studios. 160 Varick Street at Charlton Street in Tribeca. C or E to Spring Street. And there's a plaque at the site of the boardinghouse where Thomas Jefferson and James Madison stayed, at 57 Maiden Lane, between Nassau and William Streets, across from the Federal Reserve Bank. (Jefferson would have hated that irony.) A to Fulton Street. James Monroe lived at 63 Prince Street in SoHo. N Train to Prince Street. None of these structures are still standing.
Several Presidents had post-Presidency homes in Manhattan: Ulysses S. Grant at 3 East 66th Street, off 5th Avenue; Cleveland (between his nonconsecutive terms) a short walk away at 816 Madison Avenue, off 69th Street (both: 6 to 68th Street-Hunter College); and Herbert Hoover (and General Douglas MacArthur) at the Waldorf-Astoria Hotel, 301 Park Avenue at 49th Street (6 to 51st Street).
Keep in mind: These addresses, and those of the filming locations for the TV shows I'm about to mention, are private residences. Do not attempt to enter; leave the people living there alone.
No one is "buried in Grant's Tomb": While the vault where the coffins of Ulysses & Julia Grant are held is underground, by definition, no one is buried in a tomb. What is officially called General Grant National Memorial is on Riverside Drive at 122nd Street. (1 to 125th Street.)
Cleveland, like Woodrow Wilson, lived in Princeton, New Jersey -- in Cleveland's case, after his 2nd term. However, Cleveland's house, at 15 Hodge Road off Bayard Lane; Wilson's houses, at 72 and 82 Library Place, off Stockton Street; and Albert Einstein's house, at 112 Mercer Street, off Edgehill Street, are all privately owned and not available for tours. Madison, like Wilson, was a Princeton graduate, but I don't know where he lived in town.
NJ Transit Northeast Corridor Line to Princeton Junction, then transfer to a shuttle train to Princeton; or, from Port Authority Bus Terminal, take a Coach USA bus to the end of the line at Princeton's Palmer Square. The house where Cleveland was born, at 207 Bloomfield Avenue in Caldwell, is open for tours. NJ Transit 29 bus from Newark.
Chester Arthur was living in Manhattan when he was told that James Garfield had died from his assassination on September 19, 1881, and was sworn in at his townhouse. 123 Lexington Avenue at 28th Street. (6 to 28th Street.) Before he was President of the United States, Dwight D. Eisenhower was President of Columbia University, and lived at 60 Morningside Drive. (1 to 116th Street.) Barack Obama was a commuter at Columbia, living in apartments at 142 W. 109th Street (1 to 110th Street), and later to 339 East 94th Street (Q to 96th Street).
For the 3rd Presidential Debate in 1960, on October 13 -- a few hours after the Yankees lost the World Series to the Pittsburgh Pirates on the Bill Mazeroski home run -- a one-time-only split-screen format was used: Richard Nixon was at the ABC studio in Los Angeles, and John F. Kennedy was at the ABC studio in New York. For the 4th and final debate -- the only time there's been 4 debates in the general election campaign -- on October 21, just 18 days before the election, both men were at the ABC studio in New York, the old one at the St. Nicholas Arena.
* Beach distances from Midtown Manhattan, in miles:
** New York: Coney Island, Brooklyn, 13; Midland Beach, Staten Island, 15; City Island, Bronx, 16; Rockaway Beach, Queens, 17; Long Beach, 25; Jones Beach, 34; Fire Island, 53; Southampton, 90; Montauk, 122.
** New Jersey: Sandy Hook, 53; Long Branch, 57; Asbury Park, 59; Belmar, 61; Point Pleasant, 66; Seaside Heights, 83; Long Beach Island, 100; Atlantic City, 128; Ocean City, 132; Wildwood, 157; Cape May, 160.
* TV Shows set in New York. As I'm sure you've noticed, there have been so many. On I Love Lucy, the Ricardos and the Mertzes lived at 623 East 68th Street, but this address does not exist in real life; New York Presbyterian Hospital occupies where the location would be, off York Avenue.
The Odd Couple building, home to Felix Unger and Oscar Madison, is not only a real address, but the building is still recognizable from the opening credits sequence, nearly 50 years later: 1049 Park Avenue at 87th Street (4 train to 86th Street). Not far away, at 185 East 85th Street at 3rd Avenue, is the building that stood in, in the opening credits of The Jeffersons, for George and Weezy's "Deluxe apartment in the sky."
As characters introduced in All in the Family, the Jeffersons previously lived in Queens, next-door to the Bunkers, and Mike and Gloria moved into their house when they moved. Archie and Edith lived at 704 Hauser Street, which was supposedly in Flushing, but the house shown in the show's opening is in the Glendale section of the Borough, at 89-70 Cooper Avenue. Without a car, you'll need to take the E Ttrain to Jackson Heights-Roosevelt Avenue, or the 7 train to 74th Street-Broadway (same station), and then take the Q53 bus.
Sesame Street is set in New York City, and while no specific location has ever been given, the brownstone's address is 123 Sesame Street. Show creator Joan Ganz Cooney said she originally wanted to call the show 123 Avenue B -- appropriate, since that part of the Lower East Side, because of Avenues A, B, C & D, is nicknamed "Alphabet City." (123 Avenue B does exist, at 8th Street, across from Tompkins Square Park.) But since the real Alphabet City was already descending into a crime-and-drug-ridden hellhole, from which it began to escape in the 1990s, giving that actual location might lead people to want to actually visit, which was considered a bad idea.
Sesame Street was taped at Teletape Studios, at 81st Street and Broadway, from 1969 to 1992. PBS' other major kids' show then taped in New York, The Electric Company, was also taped there, from 1971 to 1977. 1 Train to 79th Street. In 1993, Sesame Street was moved to Kaufman Astoria Studios in Queens, and still tapes there. 34-12 36th Street, at 35th Avenue. E Train to Steinway Street.
A real address in a bad neighborhood was also a problem for fans of The Honeymooners: Jackie Gleason had grown up at 358 Chauncey Street in Brooklyn, and gave the address for the building that housed the Kramdens and the Nortons as 328 Chauncey, which does exist, off Howard Avenue -- and not far from Ralph Avenue (C Train to Ralph Avenue station), from which Gleason probably got Kramden's first name.
I visited in 1991, at the depth of New York's crime wave, and the building -- in the Bushwick section of Brooklyn, not in nearby Bensonhurst as was frequently claimed on the show -- was the only one on the block that wasn't a pathetic, graffiti-ridden mess. It was probably cleaned up by devoted Honeymoonies. These days, the area is probably safe in daylight, but please don't go there at night.
Welcome Back, Kotter, which aired on ABC from 1975 to 1979, was set at James Buchanan High School in Brooklyn. Head of the Class, an ABC show from 1986 to 1991, was also set in Brooklyn, at Millard Fillmore High School. While lots of New York public high schools are named after Presidents, Fillmore and Buchanan are not among them in real life.
(Manhattan has a high school named for George Washington. Brooklyn: Thomas Jefferson, James Madison, Abraham Lincoln and Franklin Roosevelt. Queens: John Adams, Andrew Jackson, Martin Van Buren and Grover Cleveland. The Bronx: James Monroe, Theodore Roosevelt, William Howard Taft, Harry Truman and John F. Kennedy.)
Gabe Kaplan, who played Gabe Kotter, had patterned his show after his own life: Before going into comedy, he had attended and taught at New Utrecht High School, whose exterior was used as an opening and closing credits stand-in for Buchanan. I can't prove it, but I think the same school stood in for Fillmore. 1601 80th Street in Dyker Heights (D Train to 79th Street).
On The Cosby Show, the Huxtables were said to live at 10 Stigwood Avenue in Brooklyn Heights, but this address is not real. The actual townhouse used for the exterior shots is in Manhattan's Greenwich Village, at 10 St. Luke's Place, off 7th Avenue South (1 Train to Houston Street).
On Sex & the City, Carrie Bradshaw supposedly lived at 245 East 73rd Street (at 2nd Avenue, and the new 2nd Avenue Subway, the Q Train, has a stop at 72nd), but the actual building shown is at 66 Perry Street, off West 4th in the Village (1 Train to Christopher Street-Sheridan Square).
On Will & Grace, the titular characters and Jack lived at 155 Riverside Drive, a real building off 88th Street. (1 Train to 86th Street.) McLaren's bar on How I Met Your Mother is based on McGee's, at 240 West 55th Street off Broadway (A Train to 59th Street-Columbus Circle). During the show's run, McGee's held viewing parties for it.
Don Draper lived down the block from Alex Russo? On Mad Men, Jon Hamm's character tells a cabdriver, "Sixth and Waverly." This could well be The Waverly, at 136 Waverly Place, off 6th Avenue. As far as I know, The Wizards of Waverly Place, on which Selena Gomez played Alex, never gave an exact address. But, like The Waverly, you could probably reach it by taking the A Train to West 4th Street.
On Seinfeld, Jerry and Kramer lived at 129 West 81st Street, off Columbus Avenue (what 9th Avenue is called north of 59th). Jerry actually did live in that building when he started out in comedy. C Train to 81st Street. Paul Buchman of Mad About You said he also lived there before moving in with his eventual wife Jamie Stemple, to 51 5th Avenue off 12th Street. Any train that gets to Union Square (4, 5, 6, L, N, Q, R).
Tom's Restaurant (or Tom's Diner, as Suzanne Vega would call it) stood in for Jerry & George's hangout Monk's Cafe, at 2880 Broadway at 112th Street, off the Columbia University campus. C Train to 110th Street. Paul & Jamie's hangout, Riff's, is actually the Old Town Bar, 45 E. 18th Street. Any train that gets to Union Square.
The NYPD's 9th Precinct is housed at 321 East 5th Street, off 2nd Avenue. F to 2nd Avenue. (Don't bother the cops going in and out of this building. They wouldn't like it.) The exterior of this building has stood in for the 15th on NYPD Blue, the 12th on Castle, and the 2nd on The Mysteries of Laura.
The 99th, of Brooklyn Nine-Nine, would be in Brooklyn, if it existed in real life. So would the 74th, from the film Frequency, a sort-of time travel movie that uses the 1969 Mets as a plot point. But none of these precincts exists. (The Sullivan family of Frequency lived in Bayside, Queens, although the film's finale was filmed under the Triboro/RFK Bridge in Astoria.)
Like Castle, the 1975-82 sitcom Barney Miller was set at the 12th Precinct, and I suspect that ABC gave Castle's precinct the same number as a tribute to the funniest cops in TV history. Richard Castle's gift to the precinct, an espresso machine, has got to be an inside joke, a reference to the awful coffee made by Detective Nick Yemana on Barney Miller. However, aside from a brief glimpse in the original opening credits, the exterior of the precinct house was never shown, and it's anybody's guess where that building actually is -- possibly in Los Angeles, where it was taped.
The exterior of Castle's penthouse loft was at 425 Broome Street at Greene Street, in SoHo. E Train to Spring Street. Castle's New York State driver's license says 595 Broome, but this location would be inside the Holland Tunnel. Kate Beckett's apartment (the 2nd one, after the 1st one was blown up in Season 2) was said to be on 3rd Street on the Lower East Side, but the actual building is on the corner of Varick and Grand Streets in Tribeca, a 10-minute walk from the Castle loft building.
In contrast, Cagney & Lacey was set at the 14th Precinct, which, like NYPD Blue's, 15th, was said to be in Alphabet City. (While Manhattan only goes to an Avenue D, Brooklyn does the whole alphabet, Avenue A to Avenue Z.) But the 14th is real, albeit better known as Midtown South. That's at 357 West 35th Street, off 9th Avenue, in Hell's Kitchen. (Despite the name, this neighborhood, home to the notorious Irish gang The Westies, is a lot better off than it was.)
The building shown as the home of the Friends is at 90 Bedford Street at Grove Street. (Monica once gave the address as 425 Grove Street, but that address only exists in Brooklyn.) There's no Central Perk on the ground floor (or a similar coffee bar nearby), but there is a French restaurant called The Little Owl, which stood in for the restaurant that Catherine Zeta-Jones (who I love), Aaron Eckhardt and Abigail Breslin started at the end of the film No Reservations, so Monica would like that. 1 Train to Christopher Street-Sheridan Square.
Some other shows were set near but outside The City. While the workplace scenes on The Dick Van Dyke Show were set in Manhattan, Rob & Laura Petrie lived in New Rochelle in Westchester County. Also living in Westchester were Maude & Walter Findlay, in Tuckahoe; and Mrs. Garrett and the Eastland girls of The Facts of Life in Peekskill.
Bewitched, Who's the Boss and Gilmore Girls were set in Connecticut, although only Bewitched was specified, in Westport. Westport was also the hometown of Josh Lyman, played by Bradley Whitford on The West Wing. That show's Toby Ziegler, played by Richard Schiff, said he was from Brighton Beach, Brooklyn. Growing Pains and Everybody Loves Raymond were set on Long Island: The former, never specified, but the houses shown in the opening credits are in Merrick; the latter, Lynbrook.
As for New Jersey: Charles in Charge was set in New Brunswick (with the fictional Copeland College standing in for Rutgers), House in Plainsboro, and The Sopranos in various places in Essex, Hudson and Bergen Counties.
Tony and his moody brood lived in North Caldwell, Satriale's Pork Store was in Kearny (the actual building has been demolished), the Bada Bing was in Lodi (its real name is Satin Dolls, and it's still open), and the diner where the final scene was, uh, shot was at Holsten's, an ice cream parlor in my original home town of Bloomfield. (Oddly, I ate there 3 times before that scene was shot there, but, due to circumstances beyond my control, I have hardly been back to Bloomfield since.)
Notable movie locations: These are in chronological order of their release -- not necessarily of when they took place:
* 1954, The Seven Year Itch: Marilyn Monroe's skirt was billowed by the air from a passing Subway train through a grate in front of the Trans Lux Theater, which stood (but no longer does) at 590 Lexington Avenue, at 52nd Street. E Train to Lexington Avenue/53rd Street.
* 1961, Breakfast at Tiffany's: Audrey Hepburn stared into the window of the legendary store, which is still open, at 727 5th Avenue.
* 1961, West Side Story: The Jets and the Sharks have initial meeting, and their final, rumble at a basketball court at Luis Muñoz Rivera School. 219 East 109th Street, between 2nd and 3rd Avenues. 4 Train to 110th Street.
* 1968, Rosemary's Baby: The Bramford Apartment is the Dakota Arms Hotel, then the home of Leonard Bernstein, later of John Lennon. (Yoko Ono and Sean Lennon still live there, but, as you can imagine, security is a bit tighter since 1980.) 1 West 72nd Street, at Central Park West. C Train to 72nd Street.
* 1969, Midnight Cowboy: Dustin Hoffman and Jon Voight were "walkin' here" at the northeast corner of 58th & 6th, in front of 67 West 58th Street -- or, if you prefer, 1414 6th Avenue.
* 1971, The French Connection: In one of the most famous car chase scenes ever filmed, Gene Hackman drives under the elevated tracks of what's now the D Train from 86th to 62nd Street in Brooklyn.
* 1972, The Godfather: The Corleone mansion, which we are led to believe was on Long Island, was filmed on Staten Island. For years now, the house has been for sale. You would think that a fan of the movie would have snapped it up by now, a la the Christmas Story house in Cleveland. No such luck. The price continues to go down. Apparently, it's an offer that has been refused. 110 Longfellow Avenue. Staten Island Railway to Grasmere.
* 1979, Manhattan: Woody Allen and Mariel Hemingway sat on a park bench in Sutton Place Park North, 12 Sutton Square, 58th Street and Sutton Place, with the Queensboro Bridge in view.
* 1984, Ghostbusters: The Stay-Puft Marshmallow Man made his appearance at Columbus Circle, although the New York Coliseum, behind him, has been demolished to make way for the Time Warner Center. A Train to 59th Street.
* 1989, When Harry Met Sally... : You wanna have what she's having? Go to Katz's Delicatessen, 205 East Houston Street, at Ludlow Street on the Lower East Side. F Train to 2nd Avenue.
If you follow these directions, you should be able to attend a game at the new Yankee Stadium, and even do other things in New York City, and be able to go home without getting hurt.
Who knows, you may even win. Maybe.