September 24, 1957, 60 years ago: The last game is played at Ebbets Field. The Brooklyn Dodgers beat the Pittsburgh Pirates 2-0 on a 5-hit shutout by rookie lefthander Danny McDevitt.
The last play was a groundout, shortstop Don Zimmer to first baseman Gil Hodges, who thus became the last Brooklyn Dodger to play in a home game. The night before, Duke Snider had hit the last Brooklyn home run.
The ballpark was torn down in 1960. In 1962, the Ebbets Field Apartments opened. By the time I first visited, on June 18, 1988, the area, on the edge of the neigbhorhoods of Flatbush, Crown Heights and Bedford-Stuyvesant, was a gang-riddled, drug-infested hole.
I last visited on December 29, 2012, and they're still a bit iffy, but a far cry from what they were in the 1980s and early '90s. Brooklyn has gone from all but uninhabitable to actually hip since then. But it will never be what it was when the Dodgers were there.
September 24, 1957, a date which lives in misery. And yet, if the Dodger fans were so great, how come only 6,702 showed up? Huh? (Well, for one thing, the Dodgers were in fourth place. For another, that was also a Tuesday night, a workday and a school night.)
The Brooklyn Dodgers weren't moved. They were assassinated. To this day, Walter O'Malley, the banker's lawyer who owned the team in part from 1942 and wholly from 1950 to his death in 1979, is despised in the New York Tri-State Area.
The story is told of two Brooklynites, both boys of the 1940s and young men of the 1950s, who went on to write for the New York Post. Pete Hamill (Irish Catholic) and Jack Newfield (Eastern European Jewish) were having lunch, and one of them said so-and-so was "the worst person who ever lived." (Shades of Bob & Ray's "Worst Person in the World" sketch, now co-opted by MSNBC's Keith Olbermann, who admits to being heavily influenced by Bob & Ray.)
And Pete says, "Let's collaborate on a column: 'The Ten Worst Human Beings Who Ever Lived.' Let's start. I'll write my three worst on my napkin, you write your three worst on yours, and we'll compare."
And each of them ended up writing the same three names, in the same order: Adolf Hitler, Josef Stalin, Walter O'Malley.
Today, of course, the more apt comparison is to Lord Voldemort from the "Harry Potter" stories. O'Malley is, for many old people originally from Brooklyn, He Who Shall Not Be Named. The one who said, "Avada Kedavara" to their childhood dreams. Lord Waltemort.
*
But at least the Dodgers still have a following among people too young to have seen them play. That is not nearly as much the case for the New York baseball Giants.
Pirate right fielder John Powers hit the last home run. The last play was Dusty Rhodes, whose 10th inning walkoff home run won Game 1 of the 1954 World Series, grounding to short. Dick Groat threw to Frank Thomas (who would return to the Polo Grounds as an original Met in 1962), and it was all over.
Unlike O'Malley, Giant owner Horace Stoneham was willing to host a proper farewell. A gathering of 11,606 saw old-time Giants such as Larry Doyle, Carl Hubbell, and, still active and recently regained in a trade, Bobby Thomson. Blanche McGraw, widow of John, was also invited.
The Giants had already decided to move. They were going to Minneapolis, home of the their top farm team, which had just opened Metropolitan Stadium in suburban Bloomington. But when Dodger owner Walter O'Malley suggested San Francisco, they went for that deal instead.
If the Giants had said no, even if they had still gone to the Twin Cities -- hence the name of the team that actually ended up moving there, in 1961, the Washington Senators-turned-Minnesota Twins -- the Dodgers would have had, for the time, astronomical travel costs, and Lord Waltemort wouldn't have been able to make the move to L.A.
Regardless, the move happened, and Mrs. McGraw said it would have broken John's heart.
Despite winning a "miracle" Pennant in 1951 and the 1954 World Series, once the Yankees surpassed them as New York's first team in the 1920s and the Dodgers also surpassed them in popularity in the 1940s, the Giants were doomed.
Stoneham couldn't afford to fix up the Polo Grounds, and he couldn't afford to build a new ballpark. He justified the move by saying, "I feel sorry for the kids, but I haven't seen too many of their fathers lately." So he moved them, lock, stock and Willie Mays, to San Francisco, and became enormously popular there.
They've usually been competitive in their 60 seasons on the Coast, but rarely won the Pennant. They won them in 1962, 1989 and 2002. Finally, they ran off 3 World Series wins in 5 seasons: 2010, 2012 and 2014. But, this season, they might end up with the worst record in the major leagues.
The Polo Grounds survived for a brief time. In 1960, it hosted the heavyweight title rematch that saw Floyd Patterson reclaim the belt from Ingemar Johansson, and the American Football League's New York Titans debuted that year as well. In 1962, the Mets arrived. In 1964, Shea Stadium opened, taking the Mets and the Titans, by that point renamed the Jets.
The same wrecking company, and the same wrecking ball (painted to resemble a baseball), that demolished Ebbets Field in 1960 then went to work on the Harlem Horseshoe in 1964. Polo Grounds Towers opened in 1966. There's a plaque on one of the towers, roughly where home plate was; and a playground called Willie Mays Field; a mural depicting the park; and the renovated John T. Brush Stairway, leading to the elevated 155th Street, which leads to the Macombs Dam Bridge over the Harlem River, connecting the area to the South Bronx and the Yankee Stadium area.
*
The Giants aren't as well-remembered and revered as the Dodgers. The Dodgers had Roger Kahn, who once covered them for the New York Herald Tribune, to write The Boys of Summer for them in 1972. By the time Noel Hynd wrote The Giants of the Polo Grounds in 1988, on the 100th Anniversary of their 1st Pennant, it was too late: Pop culture had already given the decision to the Dodgers.
The Giants survive in black-and-white clips of Bobby Thomson hitting a Pennant-winning homer while broadcaster Russ Hodges babbles, "The Giants win the Pennant! The Giants win the Pennant! The Giants win the Pennant!" and of Willie Mays making what baseball fans refer to as The Catch.
And, of course, the name "New York Giants" survives as that of one of the flagship franchises of the National Football League, whose 8 NFL Championships (including 4 Super Bowls) is more than any other sports team in the New York Tri-State Area, except the Yankees.
But John McGraw, Christy Mathewson, Mel Ott, Bill Terry, Carl Hubbell and the other Giant greats of the pre-TV era? They may as well never have existed, for those who remember them are either dead or old. And even the youngest fans who remember the Giants and Dodgers playing in New York City at all are now age 65 and up.
But the Dodgers... They had Kahn's book, to tell of Gil Hodges and Billy Cox and Elwin "Preacher" Roe and Don Newcombe, as well as Hall-of-Famers Jackie Robinson, Roy Campanella, Duke Snider and Pee Wee Reese.
And the Yankees of the 1940s, '50s and '60s have had their scribes, writing about Mickey Mantle, Whitey Ford, Yogi Berra, Phil Rizzuto and Roger Maris. The Yankee Clipper had tributes from writers as diverse as Ernest Hemingway ("Have faith in the Yankees, my son. Have faith in the great DiMaggio.") and Paul Simon ("Where have you gone, Joe DiMaggio? A nation turns its lonely eyes to you, woo woo woo.")
No one wrote poetically, or even lovingly, about where Monte Irvin, Whitey Lockman and Larry Jansen had gone. Plus, the Giants didn't have distinctive fans like Hilda Chester the cowbell lady, and Fierce Jack Pierce with his helium tank and his balloons and his "Cooookie!" cheer for Cookie Lavagetto, and the spirit-is-willing-but-flesh-is-weak musicians known as the Dodger Sym-Phony Band.
Unlike the Dodgers (who could also have laid claim to Queens, Staten Island and Long Island, but they never overtly did so), the Giants didn't have a Borough all to themselves, since Manhattan was pretty much divided between the three teams. They had monuments and plaques in center field, and they had them before the Yankees, but it seemed as though no one cared about those.
(There is some lore about the first such plaque, a memorial to former Giant Eddie Grant, who was killed in combat in World War I, but their "monument park" as a whole is rarely discussed.)
And despite being just as racially integrated as the Dodgers were during that epic 1951 Pennant race, they weren't integrated first, as the Dodgers were with Robinson. So they missed out on that special place in not just baseball history, but American history. And they weren't the Yankees, with all their championships.
And once the Mets came along, to unite Dodger and Giant fans in a common cause -- National League baseball in New York, and hatred of the Yankees and all things American League -- there seemed no point to remembering the Giants.
But they should be remembered. More Hall-of-Famers than any other team, if you count any HOFer who actually played for them, even if just for one game. More Pennants than any NL team, though it took the Dodgers until the 1980s and the St. Louis Cardinals until the 2000s to surpass them. And they made baseball big business in New York for the first time.
The New York Giants baseball team may not have been better than the New York Yankees very often after 1922, or better than the Brooklyn Dodgers very often after 1937. But they gave New York 75 years, from 1883 to 1957, and they should be remembered as something more than a pair of 1950s film clips, a few artifacts 200 miles away in the Hall of Fame's displays, and a few fleeting memories of now-old men.
There is a New York Giants Preservation Society, that keeps the flame alive. And tributes to the Dodgers aren't hard to find.
The Brooklyn Dodgers, and the New York Giants. In each case, born 1883, died 1957. In each case, may they rest in peace. In each case, may the men who moved them never know peace.
In each case, "Forget, hell!"
No comments:
Post a Comment